Home » Volume 17 No.6 > Walking through a human zoo

FILMS

Walking through a human zoo

Richard Leonard April 02, 2007

Running With Scissors. Starring Annette Bening, Gwyneth Paltrow, Joseph Cross, Brian Cox, Alec Baldwin and Joseph Fiennes. Directed by Ryan Murphy. 116 mins. Rated MA 15+.  website

In 2002 Augusten Burroghs published his autobiography, Running with Scissors: A Memoir. It purports to tell the story of his very disturbed childhood.

Augusten (Cross) is born into a highly dysfunctional family where his father (Baldwin) is an alcoholic and his mother, Deidre, (Bening) is a mediocre poet with great ambition and a mental illness. She is soon to be a barbiturate addict as well.

When her life and marriage fall apart, Deidre sends Augustine to live with Dr Finch (Cox), her psychiatrist. The Finch house is a case-study in how the mad can take over the asylum. There is the controlling patriarch, the repressed mother, an obsessive compulsive sister, another sister is a typically angry adolescent, and the adopted son is a predatory homosexual and a psychotic.

With his mother coming and going from the house and his life, Augustine has to find his way to adulthood.

This very dark tale will appeal to only a few, but a review here is warranted because others may be attracted by the star-studded cast. True to their calibre, the acting is sometimes fine indeed, but they all work so hard on such a bleak story which goes nowhere.

Running With Scissors feels like walking through a human zoo where we observe the insane antics of one caged character after another.

The only redeeming feature of this tale of abusive dysfunction is that Augustine survived it, and wrote it up. Or so he claims. The authenticity of the story behind the book is now contested, and the film opens with the disconcerting line that, "no one will believe it, but it happened." Maybe. But even as a fictional story it makes for disturbing cinema and questionable entertainment.

 

 

---

SUBMITTED COMMENTS

 

Aurora Lowe03 Apr 2007

I really enjoyed Running With Scissors and felt it was a film which wholly complements the book; it wasn't necessarily successful as a stand-alone film. I had the impression that Burroughs had told one story in the book, and allowed the film to tell the same story from a different perspective, with different emphases.

Previous Articles by this Author

RELIGION

A funny thing happened on the way to the Vatican  

Francis stood there alone for the cruellest time. This is why members of royal families never appear on balconies alone: you can only wave so often. The Latin Americans went nuts. This guy is now the most famous Argentine ever, jumping Che, Evita and Maradona. Like 'Francis', they specialise in one-name handles too, but with friends like that ... 

FILMS

Critics with the measure of a good film  

Accepting a peer award recently, Sydney Morning Herald film critic Paul Byrnes declared serious film criticism to be in trouble. 'Much of the public now believes that a great film can't be great unless the box office makes it great.' He has a point.

CONTRIBUTORS

Richard Leonard SJ  

Rev Dr Richard Leonard SJ is the director of the Australian Catholic Film Office and author of Movies That Matter: Reading Film Through The Lens of Faith.

---

FILMS

Politically correct dancing  

A new ocker comedy depicts young protégés at a suburban dance school immersing themselves in choreographies about starvation, people dying of AIDS and the nuclear holocaust.

FILMS

Finding God in the Dark: Spirituality and the Cinema  

This is the full text of a speech given by Richard Leonard SJ in Queensland on spirituality and cinema, on the occasion of the opening of a new spirituality centre.

FILMS

Jesuit premise fails but resilience of humanity proved  

As the fascinating Seven Up documentary series develops, the supposed principle of St Ignatius—'give me a boy until he is seven, and I will give you the man'—is found to be increasingly untrue.

 

SPIRITUALITY

Dan Brown’s favour to Christianity  

A good read, a tedious film, a historical mess, and great publicity for the Catholic Church. Richard Leonard looks at The Da Vinci Code.

Please fill out the following details (fields marked with a * are mandatory):
Send To Email Address*:
Send To Name *:
Sent By Email Address*:
Sent By Name *:
Text to include in email:
Captcha validation:	please enter the code above:

^ Page Top