A- A A+

What Paris did next

James Massola |  13 June 2007

Paris hilton's jail cell?In a week in which storms have wrought havoc in New South Wales, Bangladesh has been devastated by mudslides, and Hamas has threatened its would-be partners Fatah with a coup in the West Bank and Gaza strip, one item has dominated the news. It has not been climate change, although this issue continues to rightly be on the lips of politicians and citizens everywhere.

The big news has been Paris Hilton, the heiress and celebrity who is famous for being famous. Hilton has been in the news this week because she was sent to jail for drink driving. More specifically, she had already been caught drink-driving and had her licence suspended. When pulled over for a second time and asked why she was driving, she claimed not to know her licence was suspended, even though the document suspending her licence was in the glove box of her car.

Putting aside the rather obvious questions this raises, one cannot help but be drawn to examine and attempt to discern the vagaries of the case. We had, in quick succession, Paris in jail, Paris being excused on medical grounds, Paris on early parole with ankle bracelet (which must be cumbersome in heels), Paris back in jail due to a judge over-ruling a sheriff, and finally, Paris finding God and promising to stop acting 'dumb'.

One wonders what all this has contributed to the sum of human existence.

The value of a contributionIn 508BC, a man named Cleisthenes came to power in Athens. Cleisthenes was of the nobility of that city, and gifted with rank and privilege, like Hilton. He was also a democrat, in the original sense of the word, in that he believed in the equality of all before the law, and further, that all citizens should also be required to contribute to the society in which they lived.

In ancient Athens, this meant serving on juries, participating in or sponsoring festivals, perhaps serving as a soldier. The point was that one made a contribution. Cleisthenes' reforms led to a direct and empowering form of democracy that has shaped our society to this day.

Year 12 students are at present preparing for and sitting their mid-year exams. The classics students among them, few though they may be, could well have come across Cleisthenes in their studies. Almost all of them will have found it hard to avoid news of the notorious heiress.

Few would deny that teachers are a hard working lot, or that they make a real contribution to our lives. If we fail our teachers, and allow ideology to overtake common sense in the looming dispute over performance-based pay, there may well be fewer people who remember Cleisthenes. There will certainly be more who are eager to know what Paris did next, and not what she contributes to our society.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

One must realise that the "news" published in the daily press is news to the editors and journalists, not the reading public, most of whom have the common sense to ignore such trivia.

Jim Turley 14 June 2007

Perhaps Paris Hilton's life"style"should be documented only in Legal and Psychiatric reports; the consequences of her inappropiate actions should offer no inspiration to the media or public at large.
Conviction and prison sentencing in the legal domain AND behaviour modification/psychotherapy(with a COMPETENT psychiatrist)to address her Borderline personality disorder issues would seem to be the only reports which should have been written.



MAUREEN T.COUCH 14 June 2007

Athens and Paris...an interesting comparison. I think they should keep her locked up for a lot longer than 3 weeks.

Alan Stone 14 June 2007

I can think of a few of a few other 'celebrities' who contribute nothing who could do with a stint in jail, too.

roger p 14 June 2007

As of now Paris has not made a worthwhile contribution to Society. Dr Phil tells us "past experiences are a pointer to future experiences.." A prayer or two may be of help?

John Steer 15 June 2007

great article-liked the line- must be difficult in high heels!

rose heard 18 June 2007

this article reveals the despondency of material gain that is not achieved through the work of that person and therefore the learning of responsibility one learns and values through investing in a life purpose that is derived through purpose, desire to invest in one's life and purpose and as a result to achieve one's goals that one has designed for one self and thru that that to encompass the greater part in community and the part we can play in that. thank you for this article

rheard 06 September 2007

Similar articles

Muddy ovals under threat from climate change

1 Comment
Colin Long | 13 June 2007Local football and climate changeThose of us who played school or local footy in our youth remember bitterly cold days, ankle-deep mud and finding it difficult to tell team mates from opposition through the layers of mud caked on jumpers. My twelve year old has already played for more than five years, but has not experienced one of those afternoons.

Justifying civil disobedience

Michael Mullins | 13 June 2007Justifying civil disobedienceRural landowners are planning a day of "civil obedience" on 1 July to assert what they believe is their right to clear native vegetation from their land. How is this different from the civil disobedience of anti-war protestors such as the Pine Gap Four?

Why is it so hard to say sorry?

Ursula Stephens | 13 June 2007Why is it so hard to say sorry?This year's anniversaries are reminders of the importance of "sorry" in the reconciliation process. Why is it so hard to admit that most human of qualities, fallibility? Regret, atonement and forgiveness lie very much at the core of spiritual values.

Rabbit proof fence not Jigalong's only barrier

Jack Waterford | 13 June 2007Jigalong is a remote community in WA, best known for its association with the Rabbit Proof Fence. Remote Aboriginal communities suffer greatly from undeveloped nature of their economies, and the institutional barriers created to prevent them developing.

No place for truth in citizenship training school?

Erasmus | 13 June 2007No place for truth in citizenship training school?It’s an ordinary day at the Citizenship Traditional School. Citizenship questions are about Australian values – fair go, mateship, correct use of English, etc. Take the questions home and memorise the right answers.