A- A A+

Stories about God and monsters

Tim Kroenert |  16 January 2013

Life of Pi (PG). Director: Ang Lee. Starring: Suraj Sharma, Irrfan Khan, Rafe Spall. 127 minutes

Life of Pi offers two stories. Both concern a boy who survives a shipwreck and spends months adrift in a lifeboat. One is constructed from mundane albeit horrific facts; the other, from visual and mystical wonders, scenes of terror and transcendence that seek no less than to better understand God. The teller of these stories, Pi (Khan), the shipwrecked boy now a man, asks the listener to choose. One story might be true. The other concerns Truth.

It is the more mystical account that forms the bulk of Yann Martel's 2001 novel and now, Ang Lee's wondrous cinematic adaptation of it. The young Pi's (Sharma) travelling companions on the boat include a hobbled zebra, bereaved orangutan, sinister hyena, and a majestic but deadly Bengal tiger named Richard Parker. These animals are the remnants of a zoo owned by Pi's father who, with Pi's mother and elder brother, went down with the ship.

The food chain asserts itself, and soon Pi and Parker are the sole survivors. The perilous beast and imperiled boy gradually learn to share this space. In Pi's childhood his father warned him animals have no soul; that any depth Pi might see in the tiger's eyes is merely a reflection of his own humanity. This is true enough: gazing upon and living alongside Richard Parker enhances Pi's sense of wonder at God's creation, his compassion, and will to live.

Life of Pi's greatest attribute is its visual design. Lee's films are notable for their visual grandeur and sense of nature as beautiful, vast and dangerous. Here he has created, with cinematographer Claudio Miranda, imagery that far transcends the limited possibilities suggested by 'boy in a boat'. The ocean alone is richly black and full of reflected stars; radiant turquoise and awash with luminescent jellyfish; or whipped to a towering grey frenzy.

Pi is a religious pilgrim, in the lifelong sense. During the first part of the film he relates the childhood experiences that led him, to the chagrin of his rational father and sensible mother, to embrace not only Hinduism, but also Christianity and Islam, with the studiousness of a wise and curious child. Where these faith traditions offer Pi complementary ways of knowing God, his experiences on the lifeboat test and temper that faith foundation.

The storytelling theme is encapsulated by a framing narrative, in which the now adult Pi presents his fantastic account to a Canadian novellist (Spall). This device allows the filmmakers to occasionally step back from the shipwreck narrative to offer exposition. Usually this is seamless, the adult Pi's narration so nicely written and elegantly delivered by Khan that when Pi's journey resumes, we are easily drawn back into the story.

But Lee seems at times too enamoured to the act of storytelling itself. The first part of the film contains accounts of Pi's resourceful method for neutralising school bullies; the sadistic swimming lessons he endured from a friend of his father's; and a brief romance between Pi and a young dancer. These are charming enough, and do help establish character, but ultimately do not resonate in Pi's journey the way his youthful religious excursions do.

After the shipwreck — realised here in terrifying scale and detail — the film's grip might tighten or slacken, but it never relents. Among its visual and metaphysical highlights are a hallucinatory trip by Pi to the depths of the ocean; Pi and Richard Parker's sedate but eerie visit to an island of carnivorous algae; and a hysterical Pi dancing in the face of another deadly storm sent by God to reveal himself. (Biblically speaking, Pi is part Noah, part Job.)

All of which is in stark contrast to the other story, offered by Pi in the film's closing moments with the purpose of providing a version of events that it easier to believe. But believing is not the point. Pi's story (and specifically Lee's cinematic telling of it) is, both visually and thematically, an immersive experience. Plunge into its depths.

Tim Kroenert headshotTim Kroenert is Assistant Editor of Eureka Street.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Life of Pi is so visually stunning, it changed my view of 3D on film. The concept of animals having a soul looms. Life of Pi does give a sense of nature as beautiful, vast and dangerous, as Tim Kroenert asserts. But the question of why we separate ourselves as 'superior' with a soul and animals as souless troubles me still. I found the film a great message for the concept of animals as sacred - therefore why eat them? My consience can no longer make the disonnect.

Jenny Esots 17 January 2013

Tim, a review where my head kept nodding, and yes "Pi" is indeed in cinema "an immense experience". A truly wonderful tale. The book is beautifully written and well worth reading as there is more...............What a joy writer Yann Martel has shared with us...thanks!

Penny 17 January 2013

Great review Tim, you capture the magic and beauty of the film and draw attention to the questions it poses.

Mary 17 January 2013

Film review of Life of Pi. 4 stars!.

Ilona 21 January 2013

Similar articles

Bedtime flatulence and marital bliss

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert | 24 January 2013

Leslie Mann brushes her teeth, Paul Rudd sits on the toilet with an iPad. Movie poster from This Is 40Despite moments of crass humour, This Is 40 is centrally moral, even conservative in its elevation of 'heteronormative' family unity. It stands as a nuanced riposte to the simplistic assessment made by one character that Debbie and Pete 'aren't right for each other'. Marriages are complex, and even troubled ones may not be easily dismissed.

Stories about people who want to do better

Tim Kroenert | 20 December 2012

One man suffers the shame of sex addiction. For another, a quadriplegic, sex is a matter of dignity. Two couples meet for a civilised discussion about their children's behaviour, but civility collapses. An antihero embraces violence as a solution to exploitative American media. Eureka Street counts down its essential films of 2012.

Grace and intimacy in Les Miserables

Tim Kroenert | 13 December 2012

Girl from Les Miserables movie posterValjean betrays a priest who has been kind to him, and the persistence of that man's mercy despite this betrayal sets the tone for Valjean's journey. The compassion and generosity to which he aspires contrasts with the Old Testament sternness of Javert, who is both driven and tortured by a dedication to divinely ordered justice.

Sad stories of teenage trauma

Tim Kroenert | 06 December 2012

Logan Lerman and Emma Watson in The Perks of being a WallflowerAs an introvert and writer Charlie is deeply empathetic. He sees in others sad stories that reflect his own. His sister is in an abusive relationship, and his gay friend is having a secret affair with a closeted peer. In being so deeply introspective Charlie misses the destructive consequences of his own actions.

Family Christmas torture and triumph

Tim Kroenert | 29 November 2012

A Moody Christmas cast photoThis year, in my immediate family, there has been a separation, the sale of a beloved home, the purchase of another house, and the birth of a child, my nephew. If you, like me, are someone who is accustomed to Christmas Day as a 'family occasion', you may be equally aware of the fraught nature of that innocent description.