A- A A+

Melbourne medicos bring detained children into the light

Justin Glyn |  12 October 2015

When the government introduced Operation Sovereign Borders in 2013, one of the key planks of the policy was secrecy.

Herald Sun headline 'Free the Kids'To ensure the success of the new bipartisan policy of inhumanity, it was seen as important that no-one could put faces and stories to those on the receiving end — and thereby realise the horror and illegality behind what was being perpetrated, or feel empathy for the victims.

As Tony Abbott said, 'we stop the boats by hook or by crook. I just don't want to go into the details of how it's done because like a lot of things that law enforcement agencies have to do, it's necessary, it's difficult and at times I suppose it's dangerous work.'

The 'danger' in the form of the moral toll enacted on the enforcers was eloquently demonstrated by a documentary, in December 2014, on the ABC's 7:30.

Now, we have seen the wall of silence begin to crack open. Health care professionals at the Royal Melbourne Children's Hospital have begun to do what could not be achieved by reports from the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture and Australia's Human Rights Commission.

The doctors and staff are refusing to release children they treat back to the detention which caused their problems in the first place.

This is, in itself, a heroic act, given that the government and opposition had recently united in passing legislation which would potentially see the doctors jailed for two years for even reporting abuse — let alone taking public steps to prevent it.

Even more astonishing is that the newspaper which broke the story was Melbourne's Herald Sun, hardly a bastion of left-wing activism.

Then the wall cracked further. Victorian Minister for Health Jill Hennessy has come out in support of the hospital's stance — notwithstanding the implicit attack on her own party's support for mandatory detention and refoulement, and its participation in passing the Border Force Act 2015 in the first place.

Support for taking children out of detention is back in the headlines and no longer a fringe position. The conditions which children face, long known to refugee advocates but successfully shielded from the Australian public, have now become a matter of mainstream debate.

The lack of safety and family contact, the medical issues that the doctors are seeing, including 'mental illness, behavioural problems, bed wetting and trauma', and the conditions in which the children were detained, have become known in the broader Australian community.

What the doctors have done by their bravery is to begin the slow task of pouring daylight (always the best antiseptic) into this gaping wound in Australian society.

It is an indication of how badly their intervention wrongfooted the government that the initial response of the Immigration Minister was to claim that while he appreciated the doctors' concerns, 'the Defence and Border Force staff on our vessels who were pulling dead kids out of the water don't want the boats to restart' — as if the traumatisation of children by military and quasi military personnel was the means by which these military personnel were prevented from having to witness deaths at sea.

(The 'deaths at sea' argument itself has long been shown to be a furphy: people desperate enough to risk death at sea are generally fleeing something much worse on land.)

This morning the crack in the wall of omerta has become a full-blown gap. Liberal Party MP Russell Broadbent has demanded an end to keeping children in detention and Richard Marles, the Labor shadow immigration minister who helped pass the Border Force Act, is introducing a bill to allow greater transparency in the detention system.

While it is too early to say whether the changes will bite, it seems unlikely that the doctors themselves will be prosecuted — the public movement which they have begun will probably not permit that. The climate of fear and silence around asylum seekers and refugees has begun to lift and, paradoxically, the focus on asylum seekers as patients has allowed them to be seen, first and foremost, as human beings.

The doctors at the Royal Melbourne Children's hospital may just have begun to heal their country.

Justin GlynJustin Glyn SJ is studying for the priesthood. Previously he practised law in South Africa and New Zealand and has a PhD in administrative and international law.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Constant dripping wears away a stone.

Paddy 13 October 2015

Thank you Justin for your vision of and commitment to justice and healing.

M.confoy 13 October 2015

May God bless the medical and legal professionals who are leading us to a better place.

Jo Mercer 13 October 2015

The rigid policies by both major parties has a human face in these children and families. The medical profession and other health professionals are indeed taking a brave stance.

Jenny Esots 13 October 2015

'Sovereign Borders' is one of the two complex mindsets that are the cause of serious problems in the world, and that need to be adjusted as the world evolves to become one home for one great human family. The earth is there to share. 'No man is an island', and every nation needs to accept its responsibility of cooperating with all other nations for the betterment of all mankind, just as the limbs and organs of the human body cooperate for the good of the whole. The other (as yet) immature and troubling mindset is the tendency of religions, on having found and established a path up the Mountain of God, to assume it is the only such path, and, at least implicitly, to reject or belittle other religions, because of their cultural differences or degree of development. God is Constant and Universal, and this is the mindset we all need to work towards.

Robert Liddy 13 October 2015

Great article Justin. Wonderful to see the issue of children in detention taken up by staff at the RCH who know first hand about their suffering. The issue is now very much in the public domain when previously only a few groups were concerned about it, including notably Grandmothers Against the Detention of Refugee Children. Good to see Eureka Street now addressing this aspect of the morality of our border protection policy!

Maureen O'Brien 13 October 2015

And all this alongside two Royal Commissions on the mistreatment of children. Will we take responsibility for the damage done to children in detention, not to mention their families, or will we simply send them off to some other country which has even less ability to provide them with a future.

Margaret McDonald 13 October 2015

Well done to the Doctors & nurses for standing up to Turnbull & Dutton. One step at a time. Thank you also for keeping this is due in the spotlight. Concentration camps known as detention centres have to go for everyone b

Sara Aghababaie 13 October 2015

These doctors are definitely people of conscience. It is heartening to see the State Minister for Health, Jill Hennessey, back them up.The stances of Russell Broadbent and Richard Marles on the issue are also encouraging. I suspect the tide may be beginning to change in the public arena.

Edward Fido 14 October 2015

Similar articles

Kids need care not cruelty to avoid radicalisation

Andrew Hamilton | 23 October 2015

Children's WeekA particular issue in Australia is the age of criminal responsibility, which varies in different states between ten and 12. Research into brain development suggests that people cannot fully take responsibility for their actions until they are 15 years old. Responsible policy must respect the human development of the child and ensure that the response to their wrongdoing takes into account their age and does not place them in processes they can neither understand nor properly participate in.

Goodbye to not-so-great Uncle Joe

Moira Rayner | 22 October 2015

Joe HockeySo many chances, so many slips. After building a reputation as a good guy politician on Sunrise with his 'good mate' Kevin Rudd, he blew it by rescuing Rudd from drowning in a flooded river on their well-publicised Kokoda Trail expedition in 2006. Kevin 07 went on to prove he could win an election but not run a government. In memory of the kindly smiling television entertainer Hockey once was, let us hope his diplomatic success will turn on his need to be liked, not his native political acuity.

Australians dogged by Pavlovian politics

Justin Glyn | 21 October 2015

Pavlov's dog diagramWhile running a Royal Commission into domestic violence and a $30 million campaign against it, ringing the bell marked 'asylum seekers are queue jumpers' has allowed successive governments to abuse alleged rape victims with barely a word of protest from the public. Insofar as any feelings of empathy for asylum seekers exist, we tell ourselves brutality is inflicted 'to stop deaths at sea'. So successful has this Pavlovian policy been that Australian refugee policy is now the toast of German neo-Nazis.

Justice for Aboriginals grows out of recognition

Frank Brennan | 19 October 2015

No Small ChangeIt is now more than three years (and three prime ministers) since the expert panel set up by the Gillard government reported on how the Constitution might be amended to provide recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. When I read the report, my heart sank. It had put forward a comprehensive, but unachievable and unworkable proposal for change. The lesson from 1967 is that a modest change carried overwhelmingly by the Australian people provides the impetus for change.

Aboriginal footballers' MCG dreaming

Brian Matthews | 16 October 2015

Cyril RioliIn the recent AFL Grand Final, the performance of Aboriginal footballer Cyril Rioli seemed to be not much short of magic. Well, perhaps the spirit world did make a contribution. In 1844, a great throng of clans was camped on the site of what became the MCG. Perhaps, 170 years later, Aboriginal footballers, running down the race for the first time and steeling themselves for the noise, the space, the tension, find instead a great sense of intimacy as their feet hit the grass of the oval.