A- A A+

Friendlier Ghosts of Australia Days Future

Andrew Hamilton |  27 January 2016

The conventional images of the beginnings of Australia, going beyond the arrival of the First Fleet marked by Australia Day, have to do with the past and the present. Emmanuel Phillips Fox, for example, represented Captain Cook in heroic mode landing at a pristine Botany Bay. He plants the British flag, and restrains his landing party from firing two Indigenous Australians in the far distance.

Emmanuel Phillips Fox portrays Captain Cook in heroic mode landing at a pristine Botany BayContemporary images of Australia Day depict the Australian flag or the beach in holiday mode, with boats, barbies, bathers, beach cricket and blisters. The day explicitly celebrates the founding of the colony and implicitly what Australians have subsequently made of it and have handed on to newcomers.

But Fox's painting, as we might expect from a work commissioned in the year of Federation, also suggests questions about the future of Australia.

It represents the arrival of strangers bearing signs of a highly developed military and industrial and agricultural technology, into a tribal and uncultivated land where human beings lived mainly by hunting and gathering and protecting the land's resources.

It also represents the relationship of two groups of people: one from a dominant and self-confident civilisation and the other from a culture now made marginal.

The painting invites the viewer to ask what will happen when the European settlers cultivate and develop this new land and encounter both Indigenous Australians and others different from themselves.

We have had ample time to give an accounting to both these questions. We have observed the mixed effects of clearing, planting, grazing, damming, mining and urban growth on Australia. We have also seen how marginalising, killing, fencing out and patronising Indigenous Australians and taking Aboriginal children away from their families have affected their descendants.

We have seen the coming and going of the White Australia policy and, more recently, the way our treatment of asylum seekers has defined the Other as hostile. The questions posed by the painting remain alive, not simply as a way to understand our past, but also to shape our future.

They now confront us as citizens of the world and Australians. The two major challenges facing the world have to do with kindness to strangers and care for the natural world. They are not simply about adjusting our national settings but concern the future of life on earth. 

Care for the environment, the resolution of violent conflict and the responsibility of well-endowed individuals and nations to the marginalised of our world will increasingly become conditions for decent human living anywhere in the world.

Our local acceptance of Muslim Australians as full and welcome citizens, for example, is not simply a matter of decency. It will affect our security and prosperity. The way we deal with racial and religious difference in Australia is tied to the conflict in the Middle East.

If that continues to express itself in hostility between Muslims and Westerners, and the major Western intervention is through military force, the consequent flight of people from violence and the rivalry between interested nations with interests in the area will inevitably affect the world economy and promote terrorism.

A prosperous world economy will depend on the encouragement of reconciliation between different Muslim groups in the Middle East and between Muslims and others in Western societies, including Australia. This must include cooperation in caring for the millions of people who have fled from violence. A little Australia devoid of respect and compassion for the other won't do.

The need for Australia to respect the needs of the environment in the face of climate change is now clear. It is a local challenge, affecting particularly the management of water to meet the demands of cities and enable sustainable agriculture and industry, and the patterns of settlement along the coast. This would be a taxing task even without the effects of climate change.

But Australia's welfare will depend also on its cooperation with other nations in reducing emissions. This is illustrated by the way in which intolerable pollution in Chinese cities is now affecting the funds on which Australians rely for their retirement.

In the future such links will become increasingly evident and exigent. From this perspective the diversion of Australian resources to fund the expansion and export of coal seems both self-defeating and reckless.

If the image of the beginnings of Australia is one of a boatload of powerful Europeans coming to exploit the land occupied by a primitive people, a better image of future Australia Days might be of Australia sending parties to Indigenous settlements and other nations to discover how to cooperate in the great projects of reconciliation between people and of people with nature.


Andrew HamiltonAndrew Hamilton is consulting editor of Eureka Street.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

"The two major challenges facing the world have to do with kindness to strangers and care for the natural world". Andrew, in case you're not an assiduous reader of the New Statesman ... you might find this article encouraging: http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/religion/2016/01/ten-commandments-modern-age

Russell 25 January 2016

26012016 by Wayne Quilliam If identification of self makes the person, collective identity based on race, gender, ancestry, genetic makeup or cultural birthright must be the catalyst for a progressive modern society. If this is the case, how does the contemporary culture of a country such as Australia, widely purported in it’s infancy as a modern nation be restrained by the consequences of history and the legacy of regressive generational change regarding Indigenous people. Is the media to blame when delivering a confronting narrative of ‘Us and Them’, do we blame the education system for its resistance to delivering an unbiased view of history? Has globalisation been instrumental in devaluing the world’s oldest surviving culture? Or do we realise and recognise the mistakes of the past and walk together to create a new destiny. Today marks a day in history when people for another time, from another land stepped onto the shores of our ancestors and proclaimed it to be their personal property. Today I celebrate my mother and father and their ancestors from this land and of lands afar for the opportunity to be the best person I can be on this day 26012016 and everyday beyond…… A.Professor Wayne Quilliam www.aboriginal.photography

wayne quilliam 26 January 2016

A very interesting and true article about our disregard of the environment and the indigenous peoples of this land and the people who are detained in atrocious conditions!!

Elizabeth McAlpine 28 January 2016

"....Australia sending parties to Indigenous settlements'.... The original Jesuits who came to Australia (from Austria) came with two erroneous ideas. 1. They looked at the traditional capital cities of continental Europe which were in the centre of the nations, and decided that Australia's capital would also be central, and elected Sevenhill as the likely site. 2. They undertook missions to the Indigenous people, but failed to understand their deep seated commitment to age old traditions that had served and saved them for thousands of years. Unable to find common ground, they gave up. There seems to be a similar impasse with the Muslims.

Robert Liddy 28 January 2016

Similar articles

Excluding abortion protestors is a matter of dignity

Fatima Measham | 04 December 2015

Fertility Control Clinic in East MelbourneLast Friday, Victoria passed an amendment to establish a protest-free zone around abortion clinics. I find it impossible to reconcile with the idea that personhood in utero depends on whether a baby is wanted or unwanted, but I also believe bodily autonomy is integral to the dignity of women. There is such a long history of women being deprived of agency across political, economic, social, sexual and cultural dimensions, that being able to make a choice carries its own compelling morality.

Naming and renaming uni's racist monuments

Jeff Sparrow | 02 December 2015

Richard Berry BuildingFor many years, historian Gary Foley has drawn attention to the racist past inscribed throughout the infrastructure of Melbourne University. Now, some staff and students are campaigning to rename facilities linked to particularly egregious individuals, such as the Richard Berry building, named after a leading eugenicist who stole the corpses of Indigenous people for research designed to prove the racial superiority of whites. While some accuse the campaigners of politically correct censorship, in fact the past has already been censored, and the campaigners are dragging it back into the light.

Turnbull-Abbott rivalry reveals Liberals' ideological chasm

John Warhurst | 01 December 2015

Cracked blue wallHistorically, it was Labor that was dogged by splits and ideologues, while the Liberals were perceived as practical. But the ideological chasm between Abbott and Turnbull suggests the Liberals are now a broader church than Labor. The party's ideological and factional conflict will continue unabated as the government contemplates the two big public debates of its next term: a referendum on constitutional recognition of Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders and a plebiscite on same sex marriage.

Nanny State's arthritic grip contains common good

Andrew Hamilton | 03 December 2015

Bicycle helmetA cyclist since my youth, I was intensely annoyed when campaigners first tried to enforce cycle helmets. I loved the wind rushing through my hair, and believed my safety could be left to my responsibility. Others might have wondered if I overestimated my sense of responsibility. It was hardly compatible with the practice of never applying the brakes when going down hills on country roads, or with the view that traffic rules applied only to cars. Later, I came to see that individual freedom must be considered in its context of human relationships.

Say no to increasing force against detainees

Pamela Curr | 30 November 2015

Australian Border Force uniformOne of the most disturbing aspects of Border Force takeover of detention camps has been the increased use of force against people seeking asylum. Women have been especially targeted, with physical pat-downs before they come and go to medical or counselling appointments triggering panic attacks in some as it has brought flashbacks of sexual abuse and rape attacks in Nauru. Next week in the Senate, the Government is seeking even more powers to use against women, children and men in detention.