Don Dale and the failure of arntarnte-areme

11 Comments

 

MK rang me last week. She is my oldest Arrernte friend from Alice Springs and the inspiration of the educational program I came to Alice in 1988 to work for.

Iwenhe Tyerrtye: What it Means to be an Aboriginal Person. Book by Barry McDonald and Margaret Kemarre TurnerThe Ntyarlke Unit at the Catholic High School was designed to provide secondary education for Aboriginal kids from Alice Springs Town camps who had little effective primary education and were already in trouble with the law or were heading in that direction. What MK taught me was that my role was to 'look after' these kids and assist in a process of guiding them to become strong Arrernte young men and women, effective students within a western education system and good Catholics, as she is.

I recently read again MK's book Iwenhe Tyerrtye — What it Means to be an Aboriginal Person where she talks in both Arrernte and English to her mixed audience about the process of growing up in two worlds. A most important concept that she says come from the Altyerre ('Dreaming') is found in the Arrernte word arntanrte-aremele, which means looking after, holding, nurturing or caring for.

She says: 'To go hunting for animals, to care for our children, for husbands to care for their wives, and wives care for their husbands. To share everything and to look after the ones who are sick. These are just some of the things we were created for.'

MK rang me after the 4 Corners program on the treatment of children at Don Dale Juvenile Detention Centre. She wanted to talk about how the government people in that place were not 'looking after' the kids who were put there.

In western lingo we talk about a 'duty of care', but for MK and Arrernte people it is more fundamental than that. Altyerre teaches that we must care for everybody, even the people who do wrong. This is not about western, whitefella law, it is about the fundaments of how it is, from creation.

Fr Brian McCoy SJ, the Provincial of the Jesuits in Australia, has written a wonderful book titled Holding Men. He recounts his experiences as a young priest working at Balgo Hills Mission in Western Australia and ruefully admits that the effect of the mission was to sever the essential connection between the generations within Aboriginal society by taking the children and placing them in dormitories.

He says: 'One of the practices that the mission heavily influenced was kanyirninpa [holding, looking after]. As kartiyas [Europeans] took responsibility for separating and growing up children, they prevented and wounded ancient ways of social integration and reproduction ... '

 

"What happened at Don Dale is just another 'massacre' and according to MK, Aboriginal youth have that same experience on the streets of Alice Springs every night."

 

Clearly McCoy and MK have the same process in mind — 'looking after' the children is the primary role of life. It is for this that we exist, to reproduce and provide the opportunity for young people to reach their potential.

MK and I continued our conversation. She said there should be education for young people 'about their rights'. She had moved her thinking across into the western domain, the domain of human rights under Australian Law and the 'duty of care' of police and youth workers and the government to ensure that the general rights of kids are not diminished. She was no longer just talking about Don Dale. She has lived in Central Australia for 80 years and Alice Springs for 50. She knows the texture of the town implicitly.

She knows that Aboriginal kids are not perfect — the Altyerre informs Arrernte that people do bad things, even during this sacred, creative time (as does the Bible, where the second story about humans is about one son killing his brother). But she also knows that when a young person makes a mistake they do not forfeit their right to compassion and care. She sees the behaviour of the whitefella system impacting in such a way as to alienate her grandchildren from their right to arntarnte-areme.

I recently collected another of my great friends from the renal dialysis unit and as I drove her home I told her that I had seen the new publication Every Hill Has a Story, a Central Land Council sponsored compilation of Aboriginal voices from across Central Australia, to which she is a multiple contributor. I wanted to talk of her contribution about growing up in the area around Arltunga and Ross River. She, however, had other things in mind.

Before I had finished she said softly and sadly: 'it's all about the massacres'. The last massacre of Aboriginal people in Central Australia was at Coniston in 1928, and my friend is not old enough to personally remember it. But what she was saying, I think, is that the general tenor of the many stories in the collection compels the reader to consider that the experience of Aboriginal people in Central Australia post Invasion has been one of 'massacre'.

How can she say this? Because the memory and the heartbreak of existence for Aboriginal people in Central Australia is a 'sedimented' history, laid down generationally, of invasion, physical attack, dispossession, social dislocation, cultural genocide and powerlessness. The massacres happened when the whitefellas thought they had no duty of care to the owners of the land they invaded. The blackfellas have sussed that such attitudes have not changed. What happened at Don Dale is just another 'massacre' and according to MK, Aboriginal youth have that same experience on the streets of Alice Springs every night.

Many people would say that the rules at Don Dale apply regardless of colour. The behaviour of the guards, however inappropriate, was not racist. But I think what happened there was racist. Racism is a lived experience of marginalisation and powerlessness experienced by a group because of their identifying characteristics. When black kids experience Don Dale they experience racism. And it is endemic and long lasting. It is ours to erase. We can only do it by 'looking after', 'holding' these kids close to our hearts and ensuring that we empower the people of the Altyerre to do the fundamental arntarnte-areme.

 


Mike BowdenMike Bowden has worked as a teacher and community worker in Alice Springs and Aboriginal communities in the Top End.

Topic tags: Mike Bowden, Don Dale, racism, Aboriginal justice

 

 

submit a comment

Existing comments

Truly an indicatment upon Australia-locking up children, mostly Aboriginal; legislated racism is at play here as is State sanctioned abuse and tortue of children , read e.g. http://tasmaniantimes.com/index.php?/pr-article/state-sanctioned-abuse-and-torture-of-aboriginal-children-/ . Elders often speak about ongoing Genocide. I agree with MK. And, how can we fail to understand this? There are over 15,000 Aboriginal kids in Australia who have been removed from their families, communities and Kin!!! More than during the stolen generations. Did we not apologise for such practises in 2008? Did we not commit to never repeating the mistakes of our past? Kids removed, place in so-called-"protection" .. then too many end up in the criminal justice system. We must listen to and support kids- families and Kin ( the cell of societies). Listen to the people of the land-from Melbourne footage . The people heartbroken https://www.facebook.com/sophie.moore.52012/videos/10157296121515790/ . Allow the peoples solutions and right to self- determination; treaties https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nU_H0oIQy60 (8 minutes) are part of the answer n as is the need to abide by humna right principals (human dignity embedded in these) and the UN Declaration Rights Rights of Indigneous Peoples Australia agreed to this in just 2009
Georgina Gartland | 08 August 2016


A great piece Mike. Watching the slow train wreck of the Northern Territory government from the other side of the world: you have summed up this episode, along with MK, very powerfully.
Chips Mackinolty | 08 August 2016


Thank goodness for the compassion and awareness revealed in this considered article. Colleagues and I have talked about Colonial Stress Disorder as a real symptom, similiar to PTSD, but not Post-Colonial as Indigenous people still live with the compounding effects of colonisation. Yes, it is about the massacres - massacre of culture, contact, respect, acknowledgement, rights, custodianship. Bigots wilfully overlook all this compounded pain and trauma. Thank you Mike Bowden.
Brenda L Croft | 08 August 2016


I lived in Alice Springs in the latter half of the 1980s and it seems many aspects of its culture and its people's behaviour have changed little since then. One time, when I was about to drive to Darwin, I said to a young aboriginal man that when I was about half way there I would stop off and have a chat with his "uncle".. He immediately looked rather anxious, and said please don't tell him this and please don't tell him that. The "uncle" was the authority figure in his family. Not his parents. Their role was to love him and they did that well.
Gerry Costigan | 09 August 2016


Thank you, why do great articles don't reach the people's who always have an answer but no insight. So many thanks for your well-informed words.
Francisca | 10 August 2016


I have admired your dedication to the education of Aboriginal children within both white and Aboriginal cultures, Mr Bowden. Like most, if not all, advocates for a cause, however, it does seem sometimes that there could be a few blind spots here and there. Referring to MK, you write, "She knows that Aboriginal kids are not perfect - ". Might I suggest that all children of all races are born perfect in their innocence and lack of sophistication. Their growth to maturity is a feature of their growing experience, and largely due to parental guidance and environmental experience. The adult Aboriginal community has much to answer for in the development of its children. Many have abandoned their responsibilities which has nothing to do with "invasion" other than perhaps that the invasion brought with it both alcohol and well-intentioned, inexperienced, tunnel vision Christian missionaries, some of whom respected Aboriginal culture and some of whom didn't. You, good Sir, fit into the former category. Some balance needs to be applied, however, apportioning blame to both "white Anglo-Saxon" and Aboriginal cultures. The Jesuitical "Give me the boy to the age of seven" adage in todays world of researched childhood psychology has reduced the time span to 3 years with a further 4 years that modifies the formative 3 according to environmental influences. Perhaps those who removed children from their native environment were inadvertently doing the right thing after all! In todays world an environment of drunkenness, dependence and abuse of women and children must share a large part of the blame for the sadness that attaches to the development of young Aboriginal children. For all the "sins" of the colonists and missionaries of yesteryear, it simply has to be admitted they did some good, producing some of the Aboriginal community's greatest and most effective advocates, like MK, Eddie Gilbert, Noel Pearson, Stan Grant and Yvonne Goolagong, All of these called for balance, Time to embrace it and leave the stereotypical biases in the past where they belong. Then we might begin to progress in both cultures. Time also for the Aboriginal community to face its own shortcomings in relation to some of its children. A treaty would seem to be what is needed simply because a treaty has "recognition" built into it.
john frawley | 10 August 2016


A wonderful article. I particularly like the concept of a 'sedimented history'. Like the underground rivers of blood the Irish remember. I also liked the concept of Colonial Stress Disorder. Thanks for your articles Mike.
Steve sinn | 10 August 2016


Dear John Frawley, I think that you do not appreciate the effect that a centuries long history of colonisation, slavery and exploitation at the hands of powerful nations has on people. Worldwide, there are examples of people who have struggled successfully to resist the generations of oppression. They are usually regarded as terrorists against whom various kinds of war are justified and directed. the wound heals slowly at about the same rate as our change of heart takes place. We all have splinters in our eyes. Who will claim the right to remove the splinter? Who will we trust to help us remove them?
alex nelson | 10 August 2016


"Racism is a lived experience..." When aboriginal kids feel they are being treated the way they are is because of their aboriginal inherited characteristics - no matter what the motivation or rationale of those treating them in a way that marginalises or disempowers (i.e. mistreats) them - then they are experiencing racism. One might call it received racism. Some of those mistreating the aboriginal kids may not always be conscious of the beliefs, motivations, attitudes, that drive their mistreatment but many of them will. And they will feel their behaviour is justified because aboriginal kids are different. I think there is a wide spectrum of beliefs etc among those mistreat aboriginal kids on racist grounds - from those who think aboriginals are inferior and need to be lifted up to those who think aboriginal are so inferior that nothing can lift them up. Is there a solution? We have to recognise the personal dignity of every human being.. If I find it hard put this into practice when I'm driving in Sydney traffic, why should I be surprised that workers in the criminal justice system have difficulty in practising this belief?
Uncle Pat | 10 August 2016


Thank you, Michael Bowden for this wonderful article. It is too easy to isolate the horrid behaviour to one institution and to one group of people. Whereas, Margaret K. shows us how important it is to take the long view and the higher perspective: we are definitely living in a very violent society and in spite of all the 'care talk' when it comes to real caring we see the awful truth: schools, churches, government institutions, nursing homes, and most of all violence at home. Nothing short of a culture change is needed: where do we start? We start with ourselves, with discipline and responsibility for our own individual situation and that will give us strength to help others. We also must require strongly through campaign and protest that our 'leaders' do their job with integrity and foresight: lead and inspire people rather than chasing their vote. There are many people who are mindful and compassionate and not racist: to nurture those and show them how to harness their sources would be a very good start. Keep on writing, and instructing us. I will be reading the books you refer too. Thank you. Best regards, Antonina
antonina bivona | 11 August 2016


Well said Mike and MK! It is a very complicated and messy situtation but it doesn't mean we can walk away. The NT Government must be called to account.
Robyn Williams | 12 August 2016


Similar Articles

Market economics not the solution for human services

  • Roland Manderson
  • 12 August 2016

There is a joke about a man looking for a coin under a streetlight: he had dropped it elsewhere, in the dark, but was looking under the streetlight because he could see more clearly there. In the same way, the thinking behind the Productivity Commission inquiry into increasing competition, contestability and informed user choice in human services is fundamentally flawed. The complexity and interconnectedness of human services is too challenging for market economics to properly address.

READ MORE

Nauru Files reinforce the need for political grace

  • Fatima Measham
  • 11 August 2016

The Guardian has released incident reports that lay bare the details of life on Nauru for people detained under our immigration regime. It is an 8000-page indictment of the ethical and moral character of this country. We've been here before. We already know that the torment of children does not move the political class, nor do the indignities meted out to women. Men have died under circumstances that flow from decisions nominally made on our behalf. What would it take to break the impasse?

READ MORE

We've updated our privacy policy.

Click to review