Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

MEDIA

Trickle-down white feminism doesn't cut it

  • 27 June 2018

 

Earlier this month, Business Chicks unveiled their latest Latte Magazine cover, sparking controversy for its glaring lack of women of colour.

The glossy façade featured fashionably colour-coded women accompanied by the text: 'Tracey Spicer and the women dismantling discrimination', in reference to Spicer's newly unleashed NOW Australia.

Backlash inevitably followed, with many taking to social media to point out the problem of largely white women as self-proclaimed spearheads of a movement while missing the mark with representation.

Business Chicks sought to defend and diffuse, reassuring commenters that 'diversity was absolutely considered for this cover'.

However, NOW member Nareen Young spoke out in response to the cover, stating, 'I'm on the NOW board. I didn't know about it and I am beyond furious. And I've just seen Instagram and some of what has been offered up. Shameful and embarrassing. Considering position.'

#MeToo, a movement founded and nurtured by Tarana Burke (a civil rights activist and a woman of colour), was intended to be collective and accessible. By contrast, in Australia we are increasingly seeing a mainstream picture of women's liberation that ignores a longstanding struggle for diversity, genuine inclusiveness and radicalism.

Instead, the movement continues to be appropriated by corporate 'feminists' leveraging themes of oppression to gain various forms of capital.

 

"The problem with this approach is that it fails to reach and empower women on the fringes, or those determined to take a different path than the corporate one."

 

In April, Spicer openly admitted that NOW Australia 'unashamedly' reaches for the centre, noting she'd been 'attacked by both the extreme left and extreme right'.

Business Chicks speaks similarly to the empowered, middle-class corporate woman with her eye on a seat at the table.

The problem with this approach is that it fails to reach and empower women on the fringes, or those determined to take a different path than the corporate one — that is, envisaging the tearing down and reimagining of the very structures that breed and strengthen oppression.

Rather, the decision to put nearly all white women on the cover of a business magazine highlights an exclusive path available to the wealthy and those willing to navigate the status quo rather than challenge it.

The business landscape is saturated with this kind of thinking. The rhetoric of women-focused organisations that spruik 'mumpreneurs', 'She-E-Os' and #GirlBoss ambassadors inadvertently emphasises women as 'the other', whose inspiration can be drawn from hyper gendered semantics and futile notions of 'girl power'.

Take Business Chick's international