A- A A+

Victory claimed in Mosul, but other battles loom

2 Comments
William Gourlay |  13 July 2017

 

With ongoing celebrations in Baghdad and scenes of devastation in Mosul, Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi has announced the 'liberation' of Iraq's second-largest city from ISIS. This moment, after an umbrella force of military units fought for nine months to relieve Mosul of the ISIS yoke, represents a victory for the people and government of Iraq.

An operation to retake western Mosul, 6 March 2017After the battle, however, many challenges loom, among them reconciling conflicting interests amongst Iraq's peoples and restoring the ravaged landscape. Mosul affords a picture of Iraq in miniature: its little-recognised history, its suffering under repressive regimes, its potential and the perils that it still faces.

While in the popular imagination Iraq is often equated with Saddam Hussein's brutal rule and its demographics reduced to an intractable Sunni-Shiite divide, Mosul testifies to Iraq's illustrious history and its human diversity. Among locals it is known as the 'pearl of Iraq'.

Like other cities in Mesopotamia, Mosul was a seat of learning and scholarship during the golden age of the Abbasid caliphs. Marco Polo, visiting in the late 13th century, noted its mix of Arabs, Kurds and Christians of several denominations.

Until the arrival of ISIS, the city was home to one of the most important universities in the Middle East. Within Mosul and its surrounds are many churches, the tombs of biblical prophets Jonah and Daniel, and a diverse population of Arabs, Kurds, Assyrians, Armenians, Turkmens, Yezidis and Mandaeans.

Mosul's very diversity and tradition of learning were anathema to the unschooled iconoclasts of ISIS, who set about destroying the cultural, religious and historical heritage of the territory they controlled. Music was banned, toys were outlawed and severe restrictions were placed on women. Schools became targets. Students were segregated, and an austere, violent ideology was promulgated through school curricula.

Now, however, Moslawis are moving rapidly to undo the devastations and privations of ISIS's rule. On the east bank of the Tigris, in the first neighbourhoods to be relieved of ISIS, shops sprang up immediately to sell toys and dolls that had previously been banned. Even as the battle in western Mosul raged, a musician held a concert in the Tomb of the Prophet Jonas and children flocked back to schools in eastern Mosul. Child refugees from ISIS commonly remark that attending classes is their way to take 'revenge'.

ISIS militants had focused their iconoclastic fury on Mosul's pre-Islamic treasures, but also on its university, the foremost educational and research facility in Iraq. Facilities were trashed and buildings burned. In Mosul's libraries countless ancient manuscripts and books were ransacked and looted.

 

"Despite the carnage there are flickers of hope for Iraq's future as the ISIS juggernaut recedes. The campaign to reclaim Mosul saw unprecedented cooperation amongst Iraq's fractious peoples."

 

But here, too, Moslawis have sprung into action to reverse the devastation. Staff and students have emerged defiant, determined to rebuild the university's legacy and reputation. An army of students, brandishing mops and brooms, is taking a hands-on approach to reclaiming their institution, painstakingly restoring facilities and removing booby traps from campus buildings. Meanwhile, Iraqi academics, with support and donations from around the globe, are working to rehabilitate the city's libraries and replace books on shelfs.

And despite the carnage there are flickers of hope for Iraq's future as the ISIS juggernaut recedes. The campaign to reclaim Mosul saw unprecedented cooperation amongst Iraq's fractious peoples. Kurdish peshmerga, Christian militias and Sunni and Shiite forces often at odds came together to oust the jihadist group.

Enduring political tensions between Sunni and Shiite are seen as a major hurdle preventing reconciliation in Iraq. It is understood that the repressive policies of the Shiite-dominated government led by Nouri al-Maliki inflamed Sunni frustrations and gave impetus to ISIS when it arose. But at a personal level many Iraqis do not respond to sectarian rabble rousing. Iraqi Shiites stepped up to lend support to the Sunni residents of Mosul, seeing them as compatriots rather than sectarian rivals. Meanwhile, in Mosul's Al Arabi neighbourhood, Muslim volunteers demonstrated their determination to rebuild a multi-confessional city by helping with the clean-up of the Mar Georges Church once ISIS had been expelled.

Such snapshots do not mean that all will now be rosy. Iraq faces enormous challenges, not least recovering from the traumatic retaking of Mosul. Western attention has been focused on removing ISIS, but that was only the first of Iraq's trials. The task of rebuilding will be long and fraught and will require concerted international effort — precisely what was lacking after the ouster of Saddam Hussein in 2003.

More important will be national reconciliation. Iraqis may take heart that collectively they have expelled an evil from within, but here too the international community must play an active role. As Iraq's recent experience demonstrates, neglecting a country that has been so ravaged can have profoundly negative consequences.

 



William Gourlay headshotWilliam Gourlay's PhD research at Monash University focuses on the Kurdish issue in Turkey. He is also a researcher in Iranian foreign policy at Deakin University.

Main image: An operation to retake western Mosul, 6 March 2017

 

 



Comments

Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Iraq, post-Mosul, is a wee bit of a 'watch this space' scenario. Some of the vengeance being dished out to local Sunnis who may have been coerced into joining/collaborating with Isis and their families by Shia vigilantes, sometimes with the authorities turning a blind eye, does not augur well. The big question is whether the Kurds will attempt to absorb the city into 'Greater Kurdistan' - the nightmare of Turkey, and, to a lesser extent, Iran. Will the local Arabs and Kurds fight? What about the Christians? Will they be able to return? The Nineveh plain is the Assyrian heartland. The revered Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, who has been a moderating influence on Shi'ite extremists, is 86 and in poor health. If he dies the situation may become much more volatile. Many of the genuine military strategists of Isis were former leading members of Saddam Hussein's armed forces. Iraq being a strongly tribal country they may well flee to sanctuary in the 'Sunni Triangle' and then to safety in the Gulf. America and the rest of the West may need to be involved in Iraq for a long time. Otherwise Iraq might fall under Iranian hegemony.

Edward Fido 14 July 2017

Yes, this is definitely a watch-this-space scenario. So far, portents are not good - reports of revenge killings and bodies in the Tigris. However, the Kurds make no claim on Mosul - Barzani and others have said they have no plans to expand further (content with Kirkuk and Sinjar). The West definitely needs to maintain a major role in re-construction, but it's not clear if the necessary political will to do so is present.

William Gourlay 18 July 2017

Similar articles

A terrifying new arms race

3 Comments
Todor Shindarov | 07 August 2017

xxxxxToday’s highly technological era amazes us with possibilities for human growth and innovation, but in our amazement we often forget to tackle various pitfalls. Arguably, the biggest risk is the emerging military technology, about which there are many unanswered questions. We are faced with many uncertainties: security risks due to loss of competitiveness, potential control over advanced weapons by terrorists and, most importantly, reduced comprehension by the wider society—let alone any participation in the decision making process, as the frenzied pace of technological development increases.


Obamacare not in 'death spiral' because people value it

6 Comments
Lesley Russell | 22 July 2017

xxxxxObamacare, although imperfect, was soundly constructed and thoughtfully implemented. It has withstood constitutional challenges and survived endless Congressional votes to repeal and amend it. Republicans talk only about its problems and the Trump Administration has worked hard to sabotage it further, but the fact is that Obamacare is not in a 'death spiral'. It is working surprisingly well.


Judaism and dissent

20 Comments
Na'ama Carlin | 20 July 2017

xxxxxSpeak out against Israeli policies towards Palestinians and you are betraying fellow Jews. This narrative is common, and we see it today in relation to human rights organisations in Israel. It is not new. The same thing occured decades ago, when scholar Gershom Scholem accused Hannah Arendt, the author of Eichmann in Jerusalem, of lacking 'love of the Jewish people'.


Jane Goodall's quest to stem the human plague

7 Comments
Catherine Marshall | 12 July 2017

Jane Goodall and Catherine MarshallRevered for her groundbreaking study of chimpanzees in Tanzania's Gombe Stream, Goodall has spent the past three decades travelling the world in an effort to alert its human inhabitants to the alarming news: we are destroying the planet. The message seems to have been lost on those in a position to halt the change, for research scientists have just reported that a mass extinction is currently underway, a biological annihilation in which billions of regional or local populations have already been lost.


North Korea, Trump and war

6 Comments
Binoy Kampmark | 10 July 2017

Kim Jong-unThe DPRK's options in terms of defending itself against the US and its allies were always limited, leaving the way open for an assortment of pantomimes. The arsenal of the threat became normal: that, for instance, of incinerating Seoul, the possibility that Tokyo or Alaska might be targets. The show seems to be moving beyond the next boundary of what is deemed acceptable, largely because Trump deemed it impossible Pyongyang would have a viable ICBM option that could reach the US.