A- A A+

Jesuit premise fails but resilience of humanity proved

Richard Leonard |  21 August 2006

49 Up. Running Time: 136 minutes, website
Director: Michael Apted. Starring: Bruce Balden, Jacqueline Bassett, Symon Basterfield, Andrew Brackfield, John Brisby, Suzanne Dewey, Charles Furneaux.

49 UpThe entire premise of the Seven Up documentary series has been an alleged quote from St Ignatius Loyola, 'give me a boy until he is seven, and I will give you the man.' The problem with this premise is that an exhaustive study of St Ignatius’ vast writings reveals he never wrote it. Much more importantly, as this fascinating film series develops, the principle is found to be increasingly untrue.

Shot over 42 years now, 49 Up looks at how life is developing for 12 of the original 14 children whose parents or guardians agreed for them to be part of the first film in 1964. The two who have opted out did so many years ago. One is not mentioned at all now, the other’s preference not to be part of it continues to be noted.

The stories of the remaining 12 people make for moving and fascinating cinema. We meet Neil who is managing his mental illness in the most courageous of ways. Tony, who wanted be a jockey, is now a grandfather. Suzy, who wanted a nanny to raise her children, is a shy but happy mother. Symon who lived in a Barnardo home as a child is the father of six, and looking to be a foster father as well. Symon’s boyhood friend Paul, who emigrated to Australia, has been through a dark night of the soul, but has emerged to a more peaceful place.

Nick, the lad from the Yorkshire dales, now a professor of nuclear physics in the USA, has had to rethink his future. Andrew who, at seven, liked reading The Times, still does. John who liked reading The Observer and The Times rightly continues to use the series to promote his humanitarian foundation in Bulgaria. Bruce, who was the most earnest of boys, is a relaxed parent of small children. And the last 49 Upseven years have presented significant challenges for the original Eastend trio of Jackie, Lynn and Susan.

The biggest difference between 42 Up and 49 Up is how much more assertive these adults are about the intrusions this film series has made into their lives, and of director Michael Apted’s intentions in the portraits of them he has drawn. It is to his great credit that he left some of these tense exchanges in the final cut of the film.

It does not matter if you have not seen any of the previous films. Apted gives very good summaries of the previous highlights in each story.

49 Up may fail to prove that by seven years of age one’s whole life is programmed. But what it does provide is a vivid scrapbook, as Nick calls it, of how resilient humanity can be.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments


Why the 'Dr' Leonard SJ ? In my day ( I am 70 ) of Jesuit education, we were taught (told) that the Jebbies didn't use any letters indicating academic or honorary achievement except in academic documents or maybe lists of educators etc. My college didn't use that format but Stonyhurst did. And NEVER did they use the introductory qualification od 'Dr'. If a Ph.D or D.Th. was there it was always as an appendage.
So what's with thie 'Dr' Leonar for a film reviewer. Bit precocious what ?


Saw the film yesterday & really enjoyed it. Agree with your thoughts. Wasn`t it Marx that said etc?

Margaret Rush 23 August 2006

Similar articles

Heartfelt account of life in Mutijulu

Tim Kroenert | 21 August 2006Aided by stirring imagery of the Central Australian outback, Uncle Bob’s melodic vocal tones draw the viewer deeply into his description of the indigenous concept, “Kanyini”—a holistic sense of “connectedness” that encompasses family, belief system, spirituality and relationship with the land.

Explorer's physical and emotional torture

1 Comment
Ben Russell | 21 August 2006John Bailey’s new book, Mr Stuart’s Track, both shatters and affirms the myths of our history, and brings the harsh realities of the exploration of Australia to life.

Murakami's elegant connection with contemporary culture

James Massola | 07 August 2006Blind Willow, Sleeping Woman is the 12th book by Haruki Murakami in English translation, and his second collection of short fiction. This collection of short stories spans Murakami’s career, from 1978 when he sold the jazz club he ran with his wife, through to 2005.

Strong characters outlast cheesy moments

Tim Kroenert | 07 August 2006Footy Legends has its share of cheesy moments, but as a tribute to working-class Australian suburbia, and a good-natured reflection on the iconic ‘little Aussie battler’, it’s a film that will move and amuse in equal parts.

Surface reality only in DIY TV

Tim Kroenert | 07 August 2006DIY programs bulge with all manner of handy hints, as happy hosts clamour to offer their free-to-air advice. But scratch the surface, and even a friendly face can turn ugly on you.