A- A A+

Broken shoes and dead ends in China's leadership transition

1 Comment
Binoy Kampmark |  13 November 2012

Vice President Xi JinpingIt is a time of leadership transitions. The US has had its monumentally expensive election. There are changes in North Korea, now headed by a leader who has initiated modest internal reforms in an otherwise brutal state.

Then, there is the meeting of the 18th Communist Party Congress in China, where a leadership transition is taking place in strict, choreographed style. Things have been rocky in the Politburo, due to scandals involving murder and systemic corruption. The body is deeply factional and fractious, despite the public face of unity. Social media and the communication cycle have made clamping down on rumours even more difficult.

The executive body of the Congress has formalised a list of names for congress delegates to review. The favourite remains Vice President Xi Jinping (pictured), who has for some time positioned himself to replace President Hu Jintao. Yet even he has become enigmatic, disappearing from public view in September without any formal explanation, failing to make scheduled meetings with foreign dignitaries and troubling China observers.

It would seem that the problems that face China and its citizens are considerable.

Under Hu, the security establishment blossomed, and economic reforms stalled. Party officials, mindful of fears that Chinese growth has become lethargic, released figures on Friday showing that the sluggishness is abating. Output from factories, workshops and mines rose 9.6 per cent in October, from 9.2 per cent in September. Consumer spending has increased while inflation kept down to 1.7 per cent.

'What a lovely dataset to welcome in China's new set of leaders,' crowed HIS Global Insight economists Ren Xianfang and Alistair Thornton. In his drawn-out farewell address, Hu claimed that 'People's quality of life has dramatically improved. Democracy and the legal system has been improved.'

In real terms, the Chinese leadership have been mobilising their citizens for a popular platform for Beijing's sabre rattling in territorial disputes. The attempts to target Japanese companies over the Senkaku-Diaoyu Islands is one such instance, a mixture of popular indignation and state orchestration. But behind the political agitation lie genuine efforts to forge ties and bypass the heated engagements.

Realpolitik is not a citizen's priority. Chinese students are flocking to institutions in the US and Australasia. American companies seek inexpensive labour in China; its teachers, struggling to find work in their home country, do so in Beijing, one example being Jonathan Levine of New York, who found employment at Tsinghua University. For such people, 'China bashing' is distinctly off the cards.

There is also acute dissatisfaction with the politburo leaders. Hu's farewell speech has been ridiculed by some Chinese bloggers who have managed to evade the censors. One user of Sina Weibo, China's Twitter-styled platform, claimed, 'No matter if it's the new or old road, if you put on two broken shoes, how can you walk down a good path?' Another: 'Won't walk down the old path ... We only walk down a dead end.'

Australia's unimaginative perspective on China's growing and jostling power accords with Washington's. In Obama's terms, China can be an adversary or a partner. That is a difficult stance to take, given that China has become America's largest debt holder, while America is China's greatest purchaser. There is a dual strategy of containment and management, an approach that risks failing dramatically depending on how Beijing responds.

The United States is increasing its Pacific presence in naval terms, holding more exercises with South Korean and Japanese forces, and basing more troops in Australia. In real terms, the re-deployment will not see a dramatic increase in vessels, but the belligerent symbolism is unmistakable.

Australia has a very selective interest in China — it buys China's commodities, but is troubled by its increasing global influence, not merely in the consumer market, but in its hunger for resources. That hunger is both an asset and a threat.

The great challenge, argues Charles Doran, is how to integrate China into the global system without conflict, a case of identifying its 'power cycle'. Powers in their twilight, in the face of powers that seem challenging, often precipitate conflict. A similar view was expressed by Kevin Rudd to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in leaked WikiLeaks cables — seek to 'integrate' China, and if not, deploy force in the manner of a 'brutal realist'.

The new China is a complex leviathan, facing internal struggles in terms of economic reform, the role of the party, and its territorial assertions. The striking question for the new leadership will be whether they do, in fact, walk to a dead-ended future with broken shoes, or embrace a different pathway with a new set of footwear.


Binoy Kampmark headshotBinoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge. He lectures at RMIT University, Melbourne.

 



Comments

Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

We would all do well to remember that China's economy is at risk. The government has been investing in infrastructure for many decades with the return of that investment at very low if not negative levels. Moreover, the housing bubble in China is legion and will burst! Beware Australia! When China sneezes Australia will be the sick patient.

joe remenyi 14 November 2012

Similar articles

Australia's bad job of asylum seeker policy

11 Comments
Andrew Hamilton | 15 November 2012

Asylum seekerYou can tell bad policy making by the trail of broken human lives it leaves behind it. The image of asylum seekers held in tents on Nauru, many on hunger strike and at least one now in risk of death, will surely be followed by images of people withering from depression and resentment and needing medical care.


No lowly scapegoats in 'necessary' Royal Commission

58 Comments
Moira Rayner | 13 November 2012

One of the informing moments of my career as a lawyer came from the survivors of a family who disclosed that an authoritarian father had beaten and raped every one of his children — under the very eye of their mother. The Royal Commission isn't about punishing predators. It must find a way to institutionalise the right of every child to be heard.


Church sexual abuse in the media

39 Comments
Michael Mullins | 12 November 2012

Cardinal George Pell

Those paying close attention to media coverage of clergy sexual abuse might find Cardinal George Pell’s defence of the Church hard to swallow. But the weekend’s resignation of the BBC director general over mistakes in investigative reporting should cause us to treat the genre with a degree of scepticism, even though the media helps us to empathise with victims.


Why we'll never agree about abortion

35 Comments
Lyn Bender | 09 November 2012

FoetusAbortion seems to be an inherently insoluble moral and human rights conundrum. The ethical debate consists of grappling with many untenable positions. The best course may be to face this complexity rather than seek to reduce it to a final solution. 


Beyond the Obama euphoria

29 Comments
Jim McDermott | 08 November 2012

In recent weeks the US Catholic bishops insisted letters be read at Mass pushing congregations to vote Republican. That approach has been repudiated twice now. At some point they would be wise to reconsider their approach. A voice in the wilderness has its place, but so does reasoned, respectful discourse.