A- A A+

Coalition stirs the ghost of Jimmie Blacksmith

Tim Kroenert |  11 December 2013

Malcolm Fraser, Rosalie Kunoth-Monks and Frank Vincent QC in conversation In Thomas Keneally's 1972 post-colonial novel The Chant of Jimmie Blacksmith, two white clerks bicker about impending Federation. One, an Englishman, suggests that 'there's no such thing as an Australian', other than in the 'imaginations of some poets and at the editorial desk of The Bulletin'. 'The only true Australians are ... the Aborigines.' 'Jacko', his zealous young companion retorts, is 'an honest bastard, but he's nearly extinct … It's sad, but he had to go.'

The young clerk seems to be of the view, reflected by others elsewhere in the novel, that Federation represents atonement, or at least a chance to draw a line through a history of colonial hardship and Aboriginal slaughter. The novel evokes a treacherous national identity crisis; this is reflected in the person of its half-caste antihero Jimmie, who is so infected by it and so oppressed by the latent racism that it elicits, that he eventually explodes in murderous rage.

More than a century after Federation, Australia has yet to resolve this tension between a romantic notion of what 'Australia' is, and the depravities that were undertaken to attain it. It may be couched in more polite terms, but it rears its head in ham-fisted and fundamentally disrespectful approaches to Indigenous policy, such as recent moves by the Coalition Government that threaten to undercut the spirit of Native Title legislation.

Senior Aboriginal leaders and advocates for Aboriginal rights have raised concerns about a strategy employed by Indigenous Affairs Minister, Country Liberal Party Senator Nigel Scullion. During what Frank Vincent QC describes as a fly-in, fly-out mission, Scullion obtained memorandums of understanding from members of Gunbalanya and Yirrkala townships to negotiate 99-year leases.

East Arnhem elder Dr Djiniyini Gondarra describes this as being part of a 'blitz' designed to encourage other communities around the country hastily to sign similar deals, ostensibly for their own betterment. Gondarra expressed fury about the manoeuvre in The Australian: 'We … do not want further controls put over our society,' he said. 'We want the shameful march of colonisation to end.'

'The Chant of Jimmie Blacksmith' features a hand clutching a bloody axeVincent, former prime minister Malcolm Fraser, Alastair Nicholson QC and Rosalie Kunoth-Monks, outspoken elder from Utopia, NT, picked up this theme during a forum in Melbourne recently. It is 'technically correct', said Nicholson, that the 99-year leases don't negate Aboriginal ownership. But they do pit a particularly 'western' notion of ownership against the traditional Aboriginal concept of custodianship, which is at the heart of Native Title law. Taking away that custodianship for the span of four generations is as good as an acquisition.

This is not a partisan issue. As Fraser pointed out, it continues a tendency towards government interventions (such as the Intervention and its euphemistically dubbed offspring, Stronger Futures) from successive governments of both sides, that eschew consultation in favour of paternalism. This is inherently disempowering and marginalising. And the fly-in, fly-out approach negates the possibility of genuine informed consent by the signatories.

Fraser suggested that one alternative approach may be for Aboriginal communities to preempt the government interventions, enlist the support of sympathetic developers and lawyers and take development into their own hands, in a way that remains respectful of the traditional values and practices of custodianship. Even this may be easier said than done: Kunoth-Monks intimated that her own attempts to follow such a course had been stifled at (then Labor) government level by a Minister who she sensed preferred paternalism to empowerment.

What is the way forward? Gondarra calls on the Government 'in the spirit of partnership' to 'declare their interests openly and tell us why they think 99-year leases are good things, not start with the premise they are best for us and then try to persuade us. They should allow a process of option creation as our people come to the government with our own ideas. Finally with free, prior and informed consent, our people and the government can make mutual agreements that will progress Indigenous interests, not only government interests.'

In 2013 we are well past the point of lolling back on cushiony words like Reconciliation and the fading memory of the National Apology. 'We no longer want compassion,' says Kunoth-Monks, gravely. 'We want our rightful place in this land of ours.' It's time to do the hard work. An open and transparent exchange based in mutually respectful conversation, such as that proposed by Gondarra, would surely go a long way towards achieving this, and might put the ghost of Jimmie Blacksmith to bed once and for all.

Tim Kroenert headshotTim Kroenert is the assistant editor of Eureka Street.

Pictured: Malcolm Fraser, Rosalie Kunoth-Monks and Frank Vincent QC in conversation.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Yes, Warren Mundine stated recently that the government and its advisory council will decide the way forward in relation to economic development for Aboriginal communities then will be the job of engaging with people and persuading them that that is the way to. "They might not like it to start with but it will best for them in the end". Paternalism extraordinaire and no talk of genuine consultations or free, prior and informed consent.

Marlene Hodder 11 December 2013

Unfortunately white man has a lot to answer for ,sometimes we should be very ashamed of our greed .

Irena mangone 12 December 2013

As I understand it, the current government for the first time in this country's history has included aboriginal elders directly in the Prime Minister's Department for the express purpose of directing government policy on aboriginal affairs. Perhaps it is time to give it a chance - nothing is going to happen over night. This may have been suggested by some aboriginal elders who have a different opinion from Rosalie Kunoth-Monks. Fraser, incidently , has had his shot and achieved less for aboriginal Australia than he believes he did for Zimbabwe. It is long past his bedtime.

john frawley 12 December 2013

An excellent article. This has picked up on very serious concerns. Government’s push their own ideological agendas,. Taking further control way from A&TSIs is disrespectful and paternalistic!

Australia is yet to respond to serious concerns over the racist policies of the Intervention/ Stronger Futures-to United Nations & Australia’s Parliamentary Joint committee on Human Rights.

“LAND “-there are real fears over loss of A&TSI land control in the N.T. Long planned for under Howard /Brough and cemented in 2006 legislation.

Despite Government rhetoric that land will remain under Aboriginal control, it is worth listening to Alastair Nicholson AO RFD QC speak on the Dismantling of the N.T. ALRA (1975)at http://www.concernedaustralians.com.au/#V99NIC

Listen to and act on the wishes of A&TSI communities and Elders "in the N.T". It is time to take a human right approach, follow the guideline of the UN Declaration of Indigenous Peoples.

Government as minimum MUST abide by the principals of engagement elaborated by the A&TSI social justice commissioner & AHRC. These can be found in new book
"In the Absence of Treaty" (Dec 2013).

Georgina 20 December 2013

The Coalition wants to destroy the Land Rights Act in fact if not in law. The 99 year leases will take significant Aboriginal communities out of the Land Rights Act for a century. The land may never be returned to Aboriginal ownership and control.

Zelig 22 December 2013

Similar articles

The Christmas story's whisper from the edges

John Falzon | 17 December 2013

Christmas story for the poorRecently Pope Francis blasted the so-called trickle-down economic theories in his apostolic exhortation Evangelii Gaudium. Some will scorn his message as naive at best and dangerous at worst, while others will regard it as an urgent enkindling of hope in the face of degradation and despair. The Christmas story hints that another kind of world is possible.

Without jobs we're Scrooged

Michael Mullins | 16 December 2013

Auto assembly linePope Francis says: 'Work means dignity, work means taking food home, work means loving!' Some commentators criticise the government for taking an active role in maintaining employment through subsidising unprofitable industries. They miss the point that it's the government's job to promote the wellbeing of the people, and having a job is so fundamental to living in modern society.

High Court leaves same sex marriage door ajar

Frank Brennan | 16 December 2013

Rainbow coloured rope tied in a heart-shaped knot, with a wedding band strung on either sideUntil now, there was some doubt whether the Parliament's constitutional power to make laws with respect to marriage would be broad enough to include laws with respect to same sex marriage. The High Court has put this matter beyond doubt with all six sitting judges affirming that 'marriage' for the purposes of defining the constitutional power of the Parliament could not be confined to marriage in the traditional Christian sense.

Who killed the car industry?

Ray Cassin | 13 December 2013

Nose of a Holden carThe immediate responsibility for this looming economic disaster rests with the Abbott Government, and not merely because of its use of a bullying speech in Parliament by the Treasurer, Joe Hockey, to goad Holden into announcing a decision that its masters in Detroit had probably already taken. In the longer term, this should be seen as a bipartisan disaster. What happened this week was the culmination of a process that began under Hawke.

A bad Christmas for refugees

Kerry Murphy | 10 December 2013

Dead Christmas tree with decorationsLast week asylum seekers had a small win only to have it snatched away, and then were confronted by a more serious attack. Those working with asylum seekers have learned to expect abuse and derision from governments directed against asylum seekers and those helping them. Labor is only moderately better than the Coalition, but at least they occasionally made positive decisions. However these recent events have reached a new nadir.