A- A A+

Heroes and humanity in Hudson River plane miracle

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert |  14 September 2016


Sully (M). Director: Clint Eastwood. Starring: Tom Hanks, Laura Linney. 96 minutes

On 15 January 2009, US Airways pilot Chesley 'Sully' Sullenberger successfully executed an emergency water landing on the Hudson River in New York, after both engines on the passenger jet he was flying were disabled following a collision with a flock of geese shortly after takeoff. Miraculously, and thanks largely to the veteran pilot's razor instincts and resourcefulness, all 155 passengers and crew on board escaped the ordeal all but unscathed.

This is the kind of real-life heroism Hollywood 'true stories' are made of, and it was surely only a matter of time before the story of US Airways Flight 1549 got the big screen treatment. As director, Eastwood has delivered a lithe, gripping and utterly humane take that demands viewing in a theatre.

The incident itself is portrayed in near forensic detail — repeatedly, from multiple perspectives, and with epic and immersive realism (aviophobics might best stay away). When the plane makes its impact with the water, we feel the thud. During the aftermath, we share the anxiety and claustrophobia of the passengers as they attempt to exit the sinking craft, without succumbing to the panic that might rightly accompany such a near disaster.

At the same time we marvel at the level headedness of the flight crew, as they direct traffic and enact proper procedure. They, we clearly see, are as heroic as Sully; a point that the film underlines later on.

But it is the human stories and character building that make Sully memorable. At an economical 96 minutes, the film sees these deftly woven around the action.

Tom Hanks in SullyWe fist meet Sully (Hanks in a deeply nuanced and emotionally resonant performance) the day after the incident, when he is already plagued by doubts and imagining (and dreaming) of how differently things might have turned out.


"We are shown just enough of the lives of some of the passengers on the flight to be invested in their humanity, and reminded of what is at stake."


He is also already being hailed by strangers as a hero; this stands in contrast to the safety bureau investigators who question his decision making, presenting him with data that suggests there may have been a better, safer course of action to the one he took. These only feed Sully's barely contained self-recriminations.

There are other, smaller human touches that are equally as effective. We are shown just enough of the lives of some of the passengers on the flight to be invested in their humanity, and reminded of what is at stake. We spend brief, poignant moments with the air traffic controller who tries to direct Flight 1549 to safety, and then thinks he's failed. He has time to reflect at length, in isolation, on the loss of life he believes has just occurred under his watch; there is no TV in the room he has chosen and so he at first misses the story's happy outcome. These touches enhance the film without cluttering it.

In fact the only real clutter from a narrative perspective comes during the final act, in the form of a seemingly obligatory court room scene that comes with a clunk rather than a crescendo. A more elegant ending would have served Sully better. Sill it's not enough to sully what is otherwise a very good film.


Tim KroenertTim Kroenert is acting editor of Eureka Street.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

Tim, a 'clunky' court scene?? Whaat? It had us on the edge of our seat: true Eastwood skill to have a peak cinematic moment so far into such a good film.

Geraldine Doogue 22 September 2016

Similar articles

Refugee children process trauma through drama

1 Comment
Tim Kroenert | 21 September 2016

At a Sydney school, a group of teenage refugees come together to share their stories, first with each other, and then with their friends and families via a live theatrical performance. Treehouse Theatre is run by three dedicated teachers, who facilitate the sharing, and help transform the children's stories into scripts that can be performed. Their stories are yet another reminder of the human cost of conflict, and of policies that exclude and further traumatise those who are fleeing from it.

Fraught existence of a fantastic family

Tim Kroenert | 08 September 2016

Don't mistake this for an idyll. Incongruently, the youngest child has built a bone shrine to Pol Pot. The father oversees a rigorous physical exercise regime; later he will boast that they have the fitness levels of elite athletes. Yet during a rock climbing expedition, Ben is unsympathetic when one of them injures himself, insisting the boy draw on his personal resources to extricate himself from very real peril.

New adventures in David Brent's theatre of cruelty

Tim Kroenert | 01 September 2016

There are hints of darkness behind the laughs. We learn Brent spent time in an institution some time after the original 'documentary' aired. He is shunned by his band members, who see themselves as reluctant employees rather than friends. What emerges is a rather affecting portrait of a man whose self-identity is at total odds with reality, and threatening to come crashing disastrously down.

Antiheroes of the Bush-Cheney arms boom

Tim Kroenert | 25 August 2016

War Dogs is the latest in a string of films from the past few years that are custom made for our cynical times; deeply ironic black comedies and dramas featuring antiheroes who profit to the point of excess off the misery of others. Where those films dealt with the finance industry and gained relevance from the backdrop of the Global Financial Crisis, this one shifts focus to the grimier world of arms dealing, in the context of Bush era conflict in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Dying with dignity in Madrid

Tim Kroenert | 19 August 2016

The film's quiet humour leaves open many spaces for reflection on getting older, and on mortality. Tomas is uncomfortable with the subject of death, but Julian is determined to confront it with honesty and dignity. His activities during those four short days reveal he possesses a well formed conception of his own humanity and mortality that is not short of admirable. We are as sympathetic to Paula raging against her cousin's resignation, as we are to Tomas' growing acceptance.