A- A A+

Progressive evangelicals succeeding US religious right

Binoy Kampmark |  31 March 2008

religious right losing ground The religious right is losing ground in the US. But this phenomenon could be framed another way: some of its members are moving with some speed to the political left.

Progressives tend to range, according to The Washington Post, between 11 to 36 per cent of the evangelical spectrum. But the evangelical left is gradually chipping away at the conservative leviathan, a process that began after George Bush's re-election in 2004.

Their success comes along with the erosion of the Reagan consensus which in the 1980s witnessed a curious alignment of forces: fierce individualists shared the political ground with keen evangelicals and old-school conservatives. Since the 1980s, they became formidable, a force that could not be ignored. But, while a candidate like John McCain can't ignore the evangelical vote (historically it is they, more than registered Democrats, who march out on election days), their uniformity is no longer apparent.

Evangelical authors and activists such as Brian D. McLaren of Lauren, founding pastor of Cedar Ridge Community Church in upper Montgomery County, preach with a set of revised priorities. Climate change, still unmentionable — and plausibly deniable — in many parts of the conservative movement, figures prominently. Efforts at achieving social justice are underlined with vigour. A work like The Secret Message of Jesus, released in 2006, pushes for earthly labours that refocus the religious message to the just and good life.

An entry on the progressive website Pomomusings jots down McLaren's main views. The message of the 'Kingdom of God' is not, as he puts it, 'life in heaven after you die', but an active, living project Christians must undertake on earth. For Jesus, it was 'good news for the poor'; for McLaren, the Kingdom of God suggests a 'social dimension', one that confronts believers' assumptions 'about peace, war, prosperity, poverty, privilege, responsibility, religion, and God'.

The world of the afterlife diminishes in the rhetoric, as does that of a righteous, anti-welfare, nuke-loving Christ. McLaren cringes at the staple portrayal of Jesus among conservative evangelicals as a 'pro-war, anti-poor, anti-homosexual, anti-environment, pro-nuclear weapons authority figure draped in an American flag'. While his theological base has raised eyebrows among some theologians, McLaren's politics have kept him afloat. Consuming, inclusive love, rather than militant, repellent hate, drives his activism.

There are others who are hewing away at the religious assumptions of the evangelical right, suggesting its imminent demise. Detroit-raised Rev. Jim Wallis, who has put his energies into political consultancy (witness his presence at the Democratic forum on faith on CNN), argues that America has entered the era of a 'post-religious right'. The Great Awakening, published only at the start of this year, sketches such an America, one which pushes poverty to the centre of political discussion and sees fewer names on the member lists of the religious right.

America's young evangelicals, argues Wallis, are indignant at the 30,000 daily deaths from, in the words of U2's front man Bono, 'stupid poverty'. To this can be added pandemics, environmental conservation, trafficking, human rights, war and peace. This, not 'gay marriage amendments in Ohio', is what counts.

Wallis does not stop there. He cites the views of some seasoned religious activists, with Bill Hybels, senior pastor of Willow Creek Community Church claiming an interest in poverty, racial reconciliation, global poverty, AIDS and 'the plight of women in the developing world'. Another pastor, Adam Hamilton of the United Methodist Church of Resurrection, suggests fanning 'the flames of the 21st century revival within American Christianity'.

Wallis also sees a crucial transformation among the Republican's opponents, a 'levelling of the praying field'. Democrats are now seeking to shed their battle-weary secularism, promoting messages of faith. They are, as he puts in, 'coming out of the closet as people of faith'.

On the back of these progressive thinkers come organisations and centres that are marching to a similar tune. Groups such as the Centre for Progressive Christianity, based near Seattle in Washington State, regard the views of McLaren and the rising strain of progressive evangelism as healthy. One of the points of their mission stands out: developing 'strategies for evangelism that do not assume the absolute superiority of Christianity'. This is done simply to avoid contributing 'to the world's tragic divisions'.

Wallis may be overly optimistic in his prognoses. But there is little doubt that the evangelical progressives are making headway. The religious right has stalled, itself numbed by the promotional mantra of 'change'. The success of Mike Huckabee in some of the primaries was not merely a testament to evangelist suspicions of McCain, but his insistence on putting poverty reduction back into America's political conversation.

Jim Wallis' blog at the Huffington Post

Binoy KampmarkBinoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge. He blogs at Oz Moses.



Comments should be short, respectful and on topic. Email is requested for identification purposes only.

Word Count: 0 (please limit to 200)

Submitted comments

The Book God's Politics by Jim Wallis in 2005 was a godsend at a time when many Christians felt overwhelmed by the religious right.

Ray Delaney 31 March 2008

I wonder, for all of Wallis', McClaren's and Bono's supposed care and concern for the poor, how much money their fat bank accounts drip with? They are hypocrites if they keep their wealth for themselves, all the while admonishing the rest of us to allow the government to take about our $1,000 bank accounts to "help the poor." They make me sick. And also, how do they propose that we deal with the evil of human trafficking if they refuse to secure the border by which those traffickers do the vast majority of their slave trading? Any ideas Bono?

suep 21 March 2011

At last I found people who think like me. Since the hypocrisy of the Bush presidency, who hijacked the evangelical vote to achieve power and started two wars,tortured war prisoners manipulated scientific evidence to benefit his policies (global warming and effects of tobacco etc) and collapsed the economy I became disillusioned with religion.

Carlos Perez 03 November 2012

Similar articles

Rudd trip repairing Australia's damaged reputation

Tony Kevin | 11 April 2008Kevin RuddKevin Rudd's China visit is proceeding brilliantly. But by announcing Australia's interest in a Security Council candidacy to the UN Secretary-General, he may have shown his hand before Australia is able to undo the damage the previous government did to our reputation in the UN.

Time running out for Khmer Rouge justice

Sebastian Strangio | 09 April 2008Radio DialogueAfter nearly three decades of legal impunity, justice is finally catching up with the surviving Khmer Rouge leadership. But there's every chance the defendants will be dead before the courts have a chance to bring them to trial.

2020 delegates an unpredictable but dynamic mix

John Warhurst | 07 April 2008Australia 2020The productivity of the 2020 Summit will come from interplay within groups, not individual performance. It will be a big job to prevent it becoming the pushiest and the loudest rather than the best and the brightest.

Pat Dodson chooses brand Mandela

1 Comment
Michael Mullins | 07 April 2008Nelson MandelaZimbabwe's struggle for freedom took a wrong turn when Robert Mugabe opted for a strategy of vindictiveness. Recently Australia's 'father of Reconciliation' Pat Dodson identified the secret of Nelson Mandela's success in building the nation of South Africa from the ruins of the apartheid regime: Love your enemy.

Zimbabwe result could open the airwaves

Nigel Johnson | 04 April 2008Radio DialogueIndependent radio stations have been denied broadcast licences under the Mugabe regime. While some still don't trust the government to honour the election result, others believe a new beginning for free speech is imminent.