Catholic social solutions to workplace fairness


MondragonBruising industrial confrontations within Qantas and in Victorian hospitals during the latter half of last year pose pertinent questions as to whether alternative forms of ownership and control of workplaces might in some instances have more to offer than conventional wisdom may suppose.

A case in point is the great complex of worker-owned manufacturing, retail, financial, agricultural, civil engineering and support cooperatives and associated entities headquartered at Mondragon in the Basque region of Spain.

With Spanish unemployment levels following the global financial crisis standing at some 22 per cent, the Mondragon cooperatives have demonstrated impressive resilience, absorbing their share of economic hits and emerging largely unscathed.

For example, Mondragon's Eroski worker/consumer retail cooperative — hitherto Spain's largest and fastest growing chain of supermarkets, hypermarkets and shopping malls — has over the last two years experienced for the first time since its inception in 1959 losses consequent on reduced consumer demand, and only in the current financial year anticipates a return to modest profitability.

Fagor, Spain's largest manufacturer of white goods, has successfully managed down production by 30 to 40 per cent in the face of a precipitous contraction of the consumer durables market.

The cooperative group's Caja Laboral credit union — effectively Spain's ninth largest bank — is recovering from a 75 per cent reduction in its profitability, from 200 million to 50 million euros.

And following a sharp reduction in the use by the cooperatives of temporary workers, overall employment has stabilised at around 83,800.

The cooperatives' triumph is attributable overwhelmingly to key attributes that set them aside from comparable conventional enterprises.

Not to be overlooked are the conceptual framework that underlies the cooperatives, as well as the enduring solidarity and subsidiarity values that enliven them. These are the legacy to the cooperatives of their founder, the Basque priest Don Jose Maria Arizmendiarrieta.

Internalised and in part secularised as the values and framework have so largely become, they stem directly from the unswerving adherence by Arizmendiarrieta to formation in the 'see, judge, act' or 'inquiry' study circle mould, as developed within the Young Christian Workers unionist movement.

As recalled by one of the five lay co-founders of the cooperative group, 'Father Arizmendi organised specialist courses on sociology to which he invited economics professors ... His ecclesiastical training led him towards being a practical apostle. He not only tried to give guidelines on what should be the model for the ideal enterprise, but he put that social enterprise to which he aspired into practice.'

The benefits of this model of industry underpinned by Catholic social values are manifold.

Practical advantage gives rise to enduring ties of loyalty to the cooperatives by their worker members. As equal co-owners of their workplaces, members enjoy job security together with individual capital holdings, equal sharing of profits on a proportionate basis and an equal say in governance.

And members share in ownership of a unique system of secondary support cooperatives, from which the primary cooperatives draw resources including financial services, social insurance, education, training, research and development.

A high priority is attached by the primary cooperatives to the competitive advantage of cutting edge research and development. To this end, the original Ikerlan research and development support cooperative is augmented by 13 sister bodies that specialise in particular aspects of manufacturing activity and product development.

And faced, as recently, by adverse trading circumstances, the cooperatives are able to avail themselves of significant flexibilities. For example, non-members employed on a temporary basis can be put off until conditions improve.

Members can agree to forfeit or postpone entitlements such as one or more of their 14 per annum pay packets or the payment of interest on their individual capital accounts, or in extreme circumstances authorise individual capital account draw-downs.

Cooperatives experiencing reduced demand are able to transfer members to cooperatives where demand is increasing, without detriment to their rights or entitlements. And supplementary capital can be accessed from centrally held inter-cooperative solidarity funds.

Meanwhile, on hold until the economy recovers, are further major changes expressing the ongoing commitment of the cooperatives to their origins and principles. These include agreed measures to enfranchise the 35,OOO of Eroski's 50,000 retail workers who are not already members.

Some 114 local and overseas subsidiaries owned or joint ventured by the cooperatives are scheduled for conversion to worker ownership on a case by case basis, consistent with their differing cultural, legal, business and financial circumstances.

And in 2009, the US Steelworkers union entered into an agreement with Mondragon to jointly develop manufacturing cooperatives in the US and Canada, that has yet to be given effect.

A record of so remarkable a character gives rise inevitably to pertinent questions. What contribution to productivity and workplace wellbeing might countries other than Spain have to gain from attitudinal change such as Mondragon has so successfully engendered?

And why is the Church in the English speaking world so largely silent about the Mondragon cooperatives' success in bringing to fruition the long struggle in the cause of its social teachings?

Race MatthewsRace Mathews returned recently from the fifth of a series of visits to Mondragon, dating back to the early 1980s. He is a former federal and state MP. His book Jobs of Our Own: Building a Stakeholder Society details the origins of the Mondragon idea and how the cooperatives work. 

Topic tags: Race Matthews, Mondragon, industrial relations



submit a comment

Existing comments

Race Matthews has described an initiative in Spain taken in the 30s by Catholics and inspired by Joseph Cardijn, founder of the YCW. DR Matthews addressed the Cardijn Community Conference in Melbourne in November 2011 in which he outlined the Mondragon initiative inspired by Catholic Social Teaching. In his speech he paid tribute to the memory and the early work of the YCW leaders Ted Long and Frank McCann as they also established in Melbourne a co-operative, a credit union, and a large number of housing societies. They also subdivided land in Seaford, an outer suburb of Melbourne.

Race Matthews appreciates the contribution Catholic Social Teaching has played in economic and social policies in Australia as has former ACTU advocate and Australian Prime Minister Bob Hawke.

Many describe Catholic Social Teaching as the best kept secret of the catholic church and it seems that those that most appreciate this teaching are not members of the church at all!

Perhaps it is time for us Catholics to take this teaching out of the closet ourselves and have a good look at it and what it has to offer.
Kevin Vaughan, Past president Cardijn Community Australia.

Kevin Vaughan | 01 February 2012  

Excellent description of MondragonCC with an excellent question for Christian politicians.
Shann Turnbull has an informative website if one wants to learn more quickly about other aspects of the MCC story and its philosophy of corporate governance.

David Ardagh | 01 February 2012  

one is reminded of the various co-operative schemes of the 1930,s like the John Lewis partnership in England and Fletcher Jones in Victoria.Many firms in the 1980,s began to give employees shares in the company which helped to get over the traditional boss worker confrontation common in the british tradition.

john ozanne | 01 February 2012  

Still making sense. What about considering running for office again?

Joe Logan | 01 February 2012  

Great article.

John Lewis - still going strong. It's a shame what has happened to Fletcher Jones (nee 'and Staff'). We need to get smart about this and build more support for mutuals and co-operatives into the system. Even more important - we need to get some start-ups happening.

Antony McMullen | 02 February 2012  

Similar Articles

Australia follows US drone lead

  • Fatima Measham
  • 09 February 2012

Despite Obama's insistance that the use of drones in Pakistan 'is a targeted, focused effort at people who are on a list of active terrorists', civilian casualties are inevitable. Australia is also phasing in the use of drones.


Keeping Conroy out of bed with Rinehart

  • Michael Mullins
  • 06 February 2012

Communications Minister Stephen Conroy appears relaxed about Gina Rinehart's move towards control of Fairfax Media because governments are predisposed to placate media owners. A human rights charter could be the only way to maintain media diversity.



Subscribe for more stories like this.

Free sign-up