Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

Humiliation at the heart of homelessness


Average daily imprisonment rate graphAccording to data just released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics the past year has seen a 4 per cent increase in the number of people placed in full-time custody in Australia's prisons. The Northern Territory, which also has the highest rate of people experiencing homelessness per head of population, has the highest imprisonment rate (889 prisoners per 100,000 adult population), followed by Western Australia (263) and New South Wales (175).

The ABS goes on to report that:

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander males in custody increased 7 per cent and females 12 per cent from the March quarter 2012. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander prisoners represented 28 per cent of the total full-time prisoner population in the March quarter 2013. The total Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population aged 18 years and over at 30 June 2011 was 2 per cent of the Australian population.

Based on daily averages, the highest Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander imprisonment rate for the March quarter 2013 was recorded in Western Australia (4059 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander prisoners per 100,000 adult Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population), followed by the Northern Territory (2951) and South Australia (2620). The lowest Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander imprisonment rate was recorded in Tasmania (547), followed by the Australian Capital Territory (1339).

'Prisons', in the words of the American activist Angela Davis, 'do not disappear problems; they disappear human beings.' Prisons do not address the causes of poverty and inequality. They are not a solution to homelessness.

In his 2009 Social Justice Report, the then Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner Dr Tom Calma called for an alternative to this increasing rate of imprisonment of members of the First Peoples:

Justice reinvestment is a localised criminal justice policy approach that diverts a portion of the funds for imprisonment to local communities where there is a high concentration of offenders. The money that would have been spent on imprisonment is reinvested in programs and services in communities where these issues are most acute in order to address the underlying causes of crime in those communities.

Justice reinvestment still retains prison as a measure for dangerous and serious offenders but actively shifts the culture away from imprisonment and starts providing community wide services that prevent offending. Justice reinvestment is not just about reforming the criminal justice system but trying to prevent people from getting there in the first place.

Justice reinvestment is a model that has as much in common with economics as social policy. Justice reinvestment asks the question: is imprisonment good value for money? The simple answer is that it is not. We are spending ever increasing amounts on imprisonment while at the same time, prisoners are not being rehabilitated, recidivism rates are high and return to prison rates are creating overcrowded prisons.

This is a responsible and responsive alternative not just for Indigenous Australians but for all who, by extension, experience varying degrees of marginalisation, poverty, internal colonisation and disempowerment.

After this year's Budget I made the statement, in reference to the bipartisan refusal to lift the Newstart payment, that people experiencing unemployment had been deliberately humiliated by successive governments by virtue of the decision to keep their incomes so low.

Journalist Stephen Crittenden subsequently drew my attention to the beautiful statement by former Spanish Prime Minister Zapatero that 'a decent society is one that does not humiliate its members'. Taking this further, the real test is what a given society does to those who are arguably not its members; in other words, to those whom it has either cast out and cast off or refused to admit and include in the first place.

An interesting dialectic is at play here, because these practices of systematic exclusion are really 'best practice' forms of historical and structural humiliation.

In the words of the prophet Isaiah: 'What do you mean by crushing my people, by grinding the face of the poor?'

It is time we looked at homelessness in this vein. It is time, as a society, that we named homelessness for what it is; not a manifestation of poor behaviour, poor choices, hard luck or blind economic forces but rather a systematic form of humiliation, a means, sometimes as part of a continuum with incarceration, of producing outcasts, of manufacturing shame, of marking and scarring people. Our mission should be simple: to stand against shame.

As Chilean poet and Nobel laureate, Pablo Neruda, put it:

Rise up with me against the organisation of misery
... stand up with me
... against the system that distributes hunger ...

The shame that people are subjected to is deliberate and systematic because it can be avoided, prevented and replaced with an experience of respect and dignity.

It is done to people because they are members of the First Peoples or because they are living with a disability or are functionally illiterate or have been abused as children or as adults or are asylum seekers on Bridging Visas or are living in severely overcrowded conditions or are living with a mental illness or are unemployed and unskilled or are struggling to survive as a single parent or have been incarcerated on and off since they were children or have been separated from their culture and language and spiritual home, or anything else that you can imagine as being, according to the perverse logic of who is in and who is out, a cause for humiliation and shame.

Humiliation begets disempowerment. Or rage. We can condemn and humiliate people for not being able to get up the steps or we can build a ramp.

What would our economy look like if the people pushed to the margins were listened to instead of being pathologised and criminalised? What would the law, which is a reflection of economic and social realities, look like?

Could it be that we would be building more social housing instead of more prisons? Could it be that the First Peoples of Australia would be running our universities instead of filling our jails? Could it be that the St Vincent de Paul Society and other charities would be needed only to fight loneliness instead of homelessness?

St Vincent de Paul Society is holding its annual CEO Sleepout across the nation's capitals this week. We continue to be magnificently supported by the Australian community in our fight against homelessness.

We are specifically calling this year for both sides of politics to embrace a bipartisan support for the 2008 White Paper target to halve homelessness by 2020 and to offer a place to call home for all who are sleeping rough. At this stage we are yet to have this commitment endorsed by the Opposition.

The steps towards halving homelessness, let alone eliminating it, must include a guarantee of the basic human right to housing; a strong investment in education, especially focussing on students from disadvantaged backgrounds; and pathways to secure and sustainable employment, including an adequate, rather than impoverishing, income support system for those who are outside the labour market.

The theologian Karl Barth wrote: 'God always takes his stand unconditionally and passionately on this side and on this side alone: against the lofty and on behalf of the lowly.' The poet Audre Lorde says 'our visions begin with our desires'. What is God if not this burning desire for justice for all who are humiliated by the history of dispossession; a vision that has what it takes to set fire to our hearts?

John Falzon headshotDr John Falzon is a political sociologist, poet and author of The Language of the Unheard (2012). He is Chief Executive Officer of the St Vincent Paul Society National Council of Australia.

Ball and chain image from Shutterstock

Topic tags: John Falzon, CEO Winter Sleepout, St Vincent de Paul Society, Vinnies



submit a comment

Existing comments

Great article for nearly the shortest day of the year. May it herald a steady growing in the light, day by day.

Jim Jones | 16 June 2013  

As usual John challenges our perceptions. Thank you for disturbing us from our comfort.

Narelle Mullins | 17 June 2013  

It's hard to believe that the Matthew Talbot organisation have very recently closed the overnight accommodation offered to homeless men in Albury NSW, leaving the building deserted in the nights and the men on the streets. If I understood rightly, they want to encourage these men to find more permanent solutions and, in the meantime, the Anglican church seems to be the only active player trying to find an immediate solution.

william | 17 June 2013  

A poetic piece! But like all good poetry resides in a created make believe world of unatainable dreams without any semblance of reality."The shame that people are subjected to is deliberate and systematic (where is the evidence?) because it can be avoided, prevented and replaced with an experience of respect and dignity." Respect and dignity grow from one's respect and dignity for and in ones's self. Fostering that development is where we need to start.

john frawley | 17 June 2013  

I agree whoeheartedly with John Falzon when he writes,'The steps towards halving homelessness, let alone eliminating it, must include a guarantee of the basic human right to housing; a strong investment in education, especially focussing on students from disadvantaged backgrounds; and pathways to secure and sustainable employment, including an adequate, rather than impoverishing, income support system for those who are outside the labour market.' I wish this could be among the major concerns of Australians as we head towards an election. Thank you also John for that moving and powerful quote from Karl Barth: 'God always takes his stand unconditionally and passionately on this side and on this side alone: against the lofty and on behalf of the lowly.'

robert van zetten | 17 June 2013  

Here are a couple of pointers in the right direction. Many homeless are mentally ill. That's because our governments in their ivory towered wisdom threw them on the streets a couple of decades back and left many of them to self-medicate: one of the greatest acts of cruelty committed in our society in the last half century. Many other homeless are aborigines in the absurd state-manufactured constructs we call "remote communities". A third tranche are unemployed because of minimum wage laws and other union-backed coercive regulations which chop off the lowest rungs of the employment ladder plus the mountain of green and red tape that prevents people starting up small businesses. Another significant number are homeless due to marital breakdown - a chief cause of which is the introduction of no-fault divorce. In sum, Australian citizens have no reason to feel guilty about the homeless. What they need to do is punish the la-la land policies of left-inspired regimes that created the problem in the first place.

HH | 17 June 2013  

Homelessness in Australian society reflects a breakdown in relationship and care for the most vulnerable members of our community. Allowing 'others' to become isolated and ignoring their place in community are deeply disturbing behaviours and need to be countered with relationships of justice where sharing life with those who are marginalised is a priority. Perhaps our society has reached the stage where reading Jeremiah's warnings to Judah may also be helpful.

Pam | 17 June 2013  

Thanks John for your wisdom, passion and insight. I suggest each reader take up this cause in a very basic way by asking their local Federal and State political representratives to read the White Paper. And if they have read it, to make a commitment to acting on it in the Houses of Parliament.

Tony Robertson | 17 June 2013  

Australia is a rich country and our homeslessness is a result of real estate protectionism in the form of building restrictions ("standards") which elminate the freedom to build afforable homes. It's not about safety - but snobbery and aesthetics. Compared to Australia, there's relatively little homeslessness in India (per capita) because Indian people have a mechanism to house themselves and what we see as a shanty town/slum, is actually a vibrant, caring, functioning community. And I doubt if Aboriginal people living out in the open in remote communities would regard themselves as homeless. "The foxes have holes and the birds of the air have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay His head."

AURELIUS | 17 June 2013  

Thank you John. I found your paragraph outlining who are our homeless very compelling.

Marie O'Connor sgs | 17 June 2013  

Aurelius, you're absolutely correct regarding the coercive restrictions on housing supply also created by the state. It's particularly absurd in a country with such a low population density as Australia. I was looking at the demand side in my remarks, but yes, the supply side is severely affected too by senseless legislation & policy. Re. the remote communities: my understanding is that the homelessness there is counted in the figures.

HH | 18 June 2013  

John, I'm a day late commenting on this article but I'd still like to do so and hope that you see my comment. I find this piece immemsely moving - I think it is the strongest piece of yours that I have read. How can politicians show so little awareness of what the life of the marginalised is like? How can journalists not keep it at the forefront of our nation's consciousness? How can it not be at the centre of our social and political thought? Congratulations on all that you do.

Joe Castley | 18 June 2013  

Our aboriginal people are disadvantaged on every indicator, health, wealth, education, incarceration, mental illness, DV, D&A abuse and mortality. And yet Mainstream Australia likes to demonise aboriginal people, laying blame for all their disadvantage at their own feet, and demagogues like Andrew Bolt, Ray Hadley, Alan Jones and the gormless Eddie Maguire just nourish existing racist views. If mainstream white middle class Australia were invaded tomorrow by hostile aliens who robbed, plundered, murdered, raped and stole their spirituality, dignity, self esteem, wealth, land, history, mothers, children, manhood and hope, I feel sure that generations on, we proud fortunate middle class Australians would not have made it through . And yet our first Australians still stand amongst us, proudly and gently. All Australians need to know about trans-generational trauma for psychic healing to take place. I have benefited from the sins of my forefathers and my aboriginal brother has suffered. Psychic healing is real. Just talk to a first Australian about how they felt on the day of the Apology in 2008. And psychic trauma is real …. just ask Adam Goodes.

MARK MEEHAN | 20 June 2013  

Similar Articles

Spare a thought for luckless Gillard

  • Moira Rayner
  • 26 June 2013

Anyone who knows how it feels to lose a career in mid life will understand how Gillard is feeling today. Now that a most gracious acknowledgement of personal defeat has been given by the first woman to step up to the hardest political job anyone could be asked to do, we must find the time to consider and learn from what we have witnessed about how the country is run.


Rudd's second coming

  • Ray Cassin
  • 26 June 2013

Can Rudd fare any better? He is a formidable campaigner and consistently rates well above either Abbott or Gillard when poll respondents are asked who is their preferred prime minister. What is more, Labor has a success story to tell about the economy, which the Government thus far has failed to sell. Rudd tells this story without illusions.