Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site


Why the seal of the confessional should remain in tact

  • 05 December 2016


I was accurately quoted in The Australian ('Catholic Row over probe into confession', 30 November) saying, 'If a law is introduced to say that a priest should reveal a confession, I'm one of those priests who will disobey the law.' Being also a lawyer, let me explain.

Like most Australians, I have been appalled and distressed by the revelations before the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse. I hope this five year royal commission is able to provide solutions so that institutions are made safe places for children.

I am one of those Catholics who has been rocked by the disproportionate number of victims whose assailants have been members of my church in positions of trust. The Catholic Church ran more schools and orphanages than most other organisations. But that provides no excuse or justification for what went on. Nor does it provide a complete explanation for the horrific statistics.

It's now clear that prior to 1996, most institutions, including churches, police forces and state child welfare agencies, were insufficiently attentive to the signs of predatory behaviour by pedophiles.

Prior to 1996, the Catholic Church was a closed, hierarchical, opaque organisation administered by bishops who were more like feudal princes than modern accountable managers. The clericalist mindset of a celibate male clergy compounded the vulnerability of children preyed upon by church personnel.

Understandably the royal commission wants to recommend procedures and safeguards for all institutions which deal with children. If the commission's recommendations are accepted by governments and legislated by parliaments, these institutions will have to comply or accept the legal consequences.

Given the separation of church and state, the royal commission is not in a position to prescribe changes to church teaching, discipline or structures. But it is in a position to prescribe minimum standards of accountability, transparency and training.

I have no doubt abuse would have been less prevalent in the Catholic Church if some of the bishops were married with their own children or if some of the bishops were women. The state is not in a position to direct that priesthood and elevation to the episcopacy be available to married men and women. I am one of those Catholics who think the Church would be the better for such changes. Most bishops presently think the Church would no longer be 'Catholic' if such changes were made.


"I was a priest in Kings Cross for many years. On one occasion a person