Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

April is the cruellest month

1 Comment


Palm Sunday alternates between March and April. When, as this year, it is celebrated in April it keeps company with a number of days that provoke us to ask what and who matter, what and whom can you trust. If it is a cruel month, it is so because it tests, even mocks, our comfortable assumptions. In a year overshadowed by manifestations of climate change, of persistence of Covid and of the horrors of war, it is not a bad month to endure an election.

April begins with April Fools Day, when the wise person lays aside all the opinions about predictability and reliability that counted for wisdom and becomes a sceptic for the day. It is designed to trap those who believe that their own world and place in it are solid and unshakeable.

The Christian feasts during April cut deeper, entering at two levels into the lethal world of power and security. At one level they describe what God is doing; at another level they describe what human beings are doing. The Son of God enters Jerusalem, the heart of the people whom he has chosen, in order to win and to heal them. Jesus, an undefended human being, enters the city only to be rejected and ejected both from city and life.  The week from Palm Sunday to Good Friday is a reflection on God’s hospitality and human inhospitality. On Easter Sunday God’s hospitality wins at a heavy cost.

On Palm Sunday Jesus enters Jerusalem with the trappings of royal power – not walking but riding, and attended by people waving branches and singing. The trappings, however, were a mockery and critique of the way power is exercised in human affairs. Jesus had only a few followers. They were unarmed. And he came, not on a horse but on an ass, a domestic animal on which any rider looks ridiculous. It was a comic scene. He came to the seat of power as a simple human being, relying on the truth of his words and on God whom he represented. The authorities perceived both his lack of power and his insolence and had him killed on Good Friday in a way designed systematically to erase all traces of his humanity. Yet in the event Jesus’ rising from death showed God’s way of accepting humiliation to be powerful and life giving in contrast to the futility and falseness of the way of power.

That double path of scorn for the logic of power and of submission to it marks Christian faith and the stories of the Gospel. Jesus’ critique of Herod’s rule in Luke’s parable of the talents is perceptive and critical. His treatment of tax enjoins submission to taxation, but his instruction to his disciples to find the temple tax in the mouth of a fish displays a lack of seriousness about it. When apprehended, Jesus restores the servant’s ear cut off by Peter. He accepts arrest. But he exposes the corrupt nature of the trial and decides for himself which questions he will answer. He is not an anarchist but nor is he intimidated by power and institutions. What matters and who to trust are questions to be answered at a higher level.


'All these events of April have in common the felt need for a canopy of meaning and of reassurance that can be trusted, and the recurrent temptation of rulers and their apologists to construct that canopy out of demonstrations of power.' 


St Paul develops this double path in describing God’s path as one that identifies with human suffering of injustice by accepting it and so freeing humanity from its chains. It shows that human beings matter and that God is to be trusted. He endorses an acceptance of and submission to power and its economic and judicial institutions,  and at the same time a cold-eyed refusal to accept their ultimate importance and the authenticity of the values they endorse.

The story of Palm Sunday speaks to the experience of refugees. That is why throughout Australia it is associated with marches and demonstrations for refugees. Like Jesus in his entry into Jerusalem, unarmed refugees also seek hospitality in centres of power and wealth. Like him, too, they are perceived as a threat, are driven off, imprisoned, maligned and left resourceless. They make us ask what a human being is worth when stripped of power, connections and human identity and who is to be trusted when responding to them. Palm Sunday and the vindication of Jesus at Easter answer that question. Each human being is worth living and dying for. God has done so, has exposed the weakness and narrowness of governments that exclude and punish refugees, and has encouraged us to find life in hospitality to those whose life is diminished.

This year we have in our minds and hearts people who have been forced to leave Ukraine. We remember, too, the people in Afghanistan whom we have promised to help, and all the people who have had to flee from their own nations. Palm Sunday is a day to be compassionate and to be in solidarity with them as they call on us for food, shelter and opportunity to live with dignity.

This year, too, is a day for us Australians to welcome the refugees who have settled in Australia. It is also a day to remember the suffering of refugees in Australia who have been kept for many years in detention and those who are forced to live from hand to mouth on temporary visas. Palm Sunday is about an extravagant hospitality that trumps all human inhospitality. Visas are about enabling life and new beginnings. They matter because people matter.  And because they matter, so do the response of politicians to them during the coming election campaign.

On 25 April is celebrated Anzac Day. A military disaster in which many young Australians died, families lost husbands and sons, and others were left to live with physical and psychic scars, it continues to make us ask who and what matters, who and what is to be trusted. Initially it rightly reassured the colleagues and relatives of those who died in war that they still mattered, and also reminded them that power is not to be trusted, particularly in the business of killing.  It has also at times been coopted by power to say that wars matter because the forge national identity and that politicians are to be trusted when endorsing and glorifying them. In this cruel April such claims seem threadbare.

All these events of April have in common the felt need for a canopy of meaning and of reassurance that can be trusted, and the recurrent temptation of rulers and their apologists to construct that canopy out of demonstrations of power. The merit of the Christian story is to undercut the claims of power and to find assurance in God’s chosen weakness.




Andrew HamiltonAndrew Hamilton is consulting editor of Eureka Street, and writer at Jesuit Social Services.

Main image: Green palm leaves (Getty Images)

Topic tags: Andrew Hamilton, April, Palm Sunday, refugees, Ukraine



submit a comment

Existing comments

If April can indeed be seen as the cruellest month then I thought it prudent to ascertain any April connection to Cruella de vil. No luck. Bruce Dawe described the barbarity of crucifixion in these words “well this Nazarene/didn’t make it any easier/really - not like the ones/who kick up a fuss so you can/do your block and take it out on them”. (And a Good Friday Was Had by All). In remembering and reflecting on cruelty then, and now, perhaps we can show compassion and mercy is a better way than the way of “the big men who must have had it in for him” (And a Good Friday Was Had by All by Bruce Dawe).

Pam | 07 April 2022  
Show Responses

Thank You, Andy & Pam. I was lucky enough to encounter Bruce when I taught at USQ. He was the very antithesis of a lofty academic and a poet extraordinaire who made time to share his humanity with everybody.

Bruce found great comfort as a widower in later life when he married for a second time at St Pat's Cathedral. A resurrection occasion for him and all who knew him!

Michael Furtado | 13 April 2022  

Thanks Michael for info about Bruce Dawe. His poetry is a joy to read, and reflect upon!

Pam | 14 April 2022  

I'm with Pam. Dawe is one of my favourite poets. He has something to say and knows how to say it.

Ginger Meggs | 21 April 2022  

It is a pity few, if any, sermons preached from our pulpits on Palm Sunday will be the equal of this article for both its breadth of vision and insight.

Edward Fido | 08 April 2022  

Thankyou for the well written article that reminds us of the humility and trust involved in God's gift to us through his Son's sacrifice.
It is a timely reminder of the plight of refugees and how we should respond. It is a shameful disgrace that our government has so cruelly ignored many refugees for 9 years to then conveniently release them for their own political advantage this week.
Can we also be reminded of God's grace and change our attitude towards our First Nations people to support self determination as they ask.
Surely a small example of what the Christian Easter message is about.

Jan Wright | 08 April 2022  

Similar Articles

Climate change and duty of care

  • Binoy Kampmark
  • 07 April 2022

The children have been busy. On matters of environmental justice, Australia has witnessed much legal activity from youthful citizens who, despite in some cases not being old enough to vote, have stirred politics. In 2021, five lodged complaints with the United Nations over the failure of the Australian government to cut, in a meaningful way, greenhouse gas emissions by 2030.


Local governments are being pushed out of aged care. But at what cost?

  • Zacharias Szumer
  • 05 April 2022

Like the aged care sector more broadly, home care is in the process of transition as the federal government implements a system designed around the principles of consumer choice and efficiency. The push is driven by expectations that the number of Australians accessing aged care services will more than triple by 2050.