Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

Dumped-on Elders down but not despairing



Gillian Bouras named it. 'Despair is surely a great temptation in today's extremely troubled world,' she wrote recently.

Aboriginal elders oppose dump'What can one feel except helpless in the face of the stark realities that confront huge numbers of ordinary people through no fault of their own?'

She quotes the 416 BC Thucydides: 'the strong do what they can, and the weak suffer what they must'.

Last Friday 29 April, I spoke with one of those suffering people facing her own stark reality. She is not an asylum seeker, but she was thinking about them in the midst of her own great sadness.

'I'm sitting here trying to eat my weetbix and keep my thoughts calm,' said Enice Marsh, Adnymathanha Elder/Traditional Owner for the Flinders Ranges area of SA. 'But do you know what I was thinking? Originally Australia was colonised by boat people. Now we have boat people trying to get into Australia. Let them come. But colonisation is again attacking the First Nations people and poisoning their land.'

Enice and the other Adynamathanha Elders had just received the shattering news that the former South Australian Liberal Senator Grant Chapman's part-owned property Bardioota is 'at the top of the list' to be the site of Australia's national radioactive waste dump. (Politician-speak for being almost certainly the eventual site.)

The proposed dumpsite is adjacent to the Yappala Indigenous Protected Area. As one Yappala resident, Regina McKenzie, later described it, 'It's like getting news of a death.'

The situation certainly exemplifies the Thucydides analysis. In her interview for ABC's AM program an hour before our own phone conversation, Enice spoke of her 'total surprise. It's a disaster. I feel absolutely shattered.'


"In a repeat of the one of the Kimba owners' comments some months back, Chapman seems to be ill-informed regarding what will actually be deposited on the property."


Outlining the numerous times that the Traditional Owners had asked the State Minister for the Environment and the Federal Resources Minister Josh Frydenberg to visit the site, she could only conclude, 'But all this has come to no avail — it's all been totally ignored.'

On Friday Frydenberg managed to have it both ways, in what seems to be a now fashionable way to go about such announcements. 'There is no final decision.' And yet, there is only one site remaining from what was a 'self selection' offer by the original 28 property owners and the shortlisted six.

Frydenberg described the selection process to date as 'rigorous'. However, as the follow up process will now include 'technological, safety and environmental assessment', an obvious question remains about just how 'rigorous' it could really have been.

In a repeat of the one of the Kimba owners' comments some months back, Chapman seems to be quite ill-informed regarding what will actually be deposited on the property, quoting the usual presenting argument used in the former SA campaign of 1998-2004: that the dump will be for medical low-level waste from various hospitals and universities around the country.

No mention as usual that there is no need for this to be stored long term in the first place. No mention of the intermediate level radioactive spent fuel rods which arrived back from France in December, and are presently housed at Lucas Heights. One wonders when such news will be broken to the property owners and the Hawker community.

In contrast, the Adnyamathanha neighbours and other Traditional Owners are completely aware of this and decry the flawed, seemingly unscientific process where one person can offer their land with absolutely no consultation to the neighbours.

Their own Indigenous Protected Area expert research and eyewitness knowledge cites that as well as being a site replete with 'countless thousands of Aboriginal artifacts and registered cultural heritage sites', 'There are frequent yarta ngurra-ngurrandha (earthquakes and tremors). We see the ground move and the hills move; we feel the land move. At least half a dozen times each year.

'It is flood land. The water comes from the hills and floods the plains, including the proposed dump site. Sometimes there are massive floods, the last one on 20 January 2006.'

In stark contrast to the previous national dump campaign of 1998-2004 which was opposed by the state government, it seems that this time no member of the SA government has come to the defence of the extraordinary Flinders Ranges, a focal point for the tourism industry of South Australia. Wilpena is a famous tourist site of great beauty and heritage, popular with both national and international tourists.

Indeed the SA community next Friday will hear the royal commission's final recommendation to import high-level radioactive waste into our seemingly politically disposable state — disposable, now, even to our own politicians.

As Bouras concludes, despair is a temptation but there is also 'the distressing matter of indifference. Indifference can be lethal.' And what pain it gives to those like Enice Marsh who care.

But still there is resilience, and still there is hope. Not only are the Adnyamathanha determined to fight on, the five other communities that are now off the shortlist have pledged their solidarity in a continuing fight against 'this flawed process'.

Who knows the power of such leadership to break the bonds of our own indifference and despair.


Michele MadiganMichele Madigan is a Sister of St Joseph who has spent the past 38 years working with Aboriginal people in remote areas of South Australia and in Adelaide. Her work has included advocacy and support for senior Aboriginal women of Coober Pedy in their campaign against the proposed national radioactive dump.

Topic tags: Michele Madigan, South Australia, nuclear waste



submit a comment

Existing comments

Despair?? What of Hope? Is not Despair human and Hope, divine?

john frawley | 03 May 2016  

Time we start listening to the expert advice of the First Peoples of this area; the Adnyamathanha. Time to respect their deep knowledge and time to start caring more deeply and learning from them. I agree the level of 'indifference' can be lethal . Bravo continue the fight others will be with you. On another note there seems indeed very serious concerns of instability of this area and did you say this was part owned by Senator. P L E A S E!

George | 03 May 2016  

Well said, Michele.It would be so easy to fall into despair as we learn of what appears to be the culpable ignorance of our lawmakers regarding the importance and even the very nature of the land they are so intent on destroying by turning it into a nuclear waste dump. Without you who would speak out when no-one in either State or Federal politics remains silent.?

Marie TF | 03 May 2016  

Thank you Michele for your very informative and heartfelt plea. Let us hope that more of us will stand with our Aboriginal brothers and sisters.

Liz Morris | 03 May 2016  

thank you Michele. Please get on the radio with Peter Goers and tell some truth to ABC Radio 891 listeners who have been sadly mis-informed by Ian Henschke and his nuclear advocate mates.

Brett Stokes | 04 May 2016  

Thanks Michele. You seem to be the only source of real information about this.

Nicholas Jose | 04 May 2016  

Once again, Michele Madigan has nailed it - clarifying this issue, especially for all us white Australians who are asleep while ill-informed governments try to put it over indigenous people. This article is a wake up call!!

Noel Wauchope | 04 May 2016  

Well at this time there is only human to advocate for us in this shocking situation. No wonder there is despair. Thank you Michele for working so hard to save our State.

Kerry Heysen | 05 May 2016  

As a resident of one of the short listed communities I know how this poor lady feels our indigenous people by choice don't have a lot ( that's the way they have had to be for hundred thousand years or so ) but they have their country seems to be just another great slap in the face of the residents of the area , there has to be a better solution than displacing people by dumping poisonous waste on their doorstep

vic | 06 May 2016  

Well done, Michele in keeping the issue before many.

Brigette Sipa | 06 May 2016  

Madigan RSJ’s sound diplomacy alongside the Adynamathanha Elders, ‘five other communities … off the shortlist’ pulsing words with familiar negotiable value and meaning. Frydenberg, Chapman … ‘our own politicians’ plod familiar phonemes unattached to either: or sources or resources: not civilly, given not cogently. And convenient to whom? ‘For ye have the poor always with you; but me ye have not always.’ Poverty’s increasingly fewer options. ‘Always’ not ‘eternally’ whilst ‘Blessed are the poor in spirit.’ Further, ‘Noli me tangerer.’ I take to mean: Do not delude yourself: You’re Self! Certainly ‘… helplessness’ when skilled adults inform: ’Ye hafta to cut ye umbilical cord!’. Well, no! E.g. You’re dead. There’s a spade! Bury yourself! Some services are, necessarily, duteous and on honour, performed for our fellow human being. While making cogent argument ‘helplessness’ is always not an option. Taking an honourable, sacred leap with Enice, Japan and Germany, Australian Indigenous and non-Indigenous Citizens – Sorry Peoples – and an NGO Shinkansen Railway system. Reference e.g. The Snowy River Scheme, solar power, water from agricultural crops, tiny houses, … mass refuge immigration with desert knowhow resources of humans galore. Why, the PM is NOW fast-forwarding visas for some international trading: billions of tourists!

Margaret T. Newman | 07 May 2016  

Similar Articles

Five reasons the LNP's carbon scare campaign is doomed

  • Greg Foyster
  • 03 May 2016

It was as if Australian politics had regressed four years overnight. No sooner had Labor released its new climate change plan than the Coalition was resuscitating Tony Abbott's 'carbon tax' line. The Coalition's attempt to revive the defining debate of the 2013 federal election won't work. As other commentators have noted, Labor's plan has been carefully crafted to avoid the carbon tax sledge. More importantly, external factors have changed to make a scare campaign less potent.


The boat people from paradise lost

  • Lyn Bender
  • 23 April 2016

Ursula Rakova told how the sea that had been the friend of her people, was turning against them. It had crashed through and divided her island in two. Coconut palms were collapsing at the new shoreline. Food gardens were lost, as the soil was increasingly rendered infertile by salty tides that washed over them. The land that had been handed from grandmother to daughter, would bequeath no legacy to the granddaughters. The homeland of generations was disappearing before their eyes.