East Timor advances despite Australian aid failures


Flickr image by AusAid PhotolibraryThis week, Australian citizen Angelita Pires was one of 27 people brought to trial for the attempted assassination of East Timor's President José Ramos-Horta on 11 February 2008. Pires, who insists she is innocent, is the former lover of rebel leader Alfredo Reinado, who was killed in the attack.

Next month will mark ten years since Indonesia agreed to a plebiscite. Four out of five Timorese voted for independence. The assassination attempt was undoubtedly the low point of the decade.

There have been many other setbacks, including the current destabilising accusations against Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao for his role in authorising a multi-million dollar contract for a company part-owned by his daughter.

But life in Dili has improved greatly over the last 18 months. The government has injected large amounts of money into the local economy, much of it directly into the hands of the poor. On the main road through Dili, stacks of government-subsidised rice are for sale. The camps of internally displaced persons have gone, although some claim they have gone only from public view. In their place are restored buildings and new public spaces. Opposite the main hotel in Dili, where a crowded camp for displaced persons once stood, a well-equipped playground is now full of children.

In Australia, a younger generation will have the chance to learn anew about the origins of Timorese independence with the release of the major film, Balibo. It re-enacts the tragic events of 1975. Journalist Tony Maniaty's book, based on his reporting from Dili at the time of the murder of the Balibo Five, will also add to many Australians' knowledge of these events.

So what progress has Timor Leste, as the country prefers to be called, made over the last decade? In particular, how effective has the Australian Government assistance been over this period?

Contrary to many Australians' expectations, the Australian Government has a low profile in East Timor. Despite its large troop presence of up to 800, its influence often appears passive, reactive and disjointed in its dealings with the Timorese Government. Australia's three main arms in East Timor — the diplomatic mission, AusAID and the International Stabilisation Force — operate as separate entities. This lack of an integrated presence is one reasons for Australia's limited success in fostering the institutions and capacities of the new state.

In addition, there is little evidence that the Australian aid program has been effective, especially in reducing poverty. The World Bank, in a recent assessment, concedes that 'despite concerted efforts by government and development partners, human development outcomes remain low'.

Australia is the largest donor to East Timor, its aid program amounting to $117 million. But the aid funds are spread thinly across a broad range of activities. It has programs in security and justice, and public sector management. It also funds the delivery of services in health care, water and sanitation, vocational education and food security. Most expenditure is on security and governance, with less than a third allocated to health, water/sanitation, rural development and education.

But depite the breadth of its programs, AusAID is floundering. Unlike its practice in other countries, it has failed to produce a country strategy for East Timor, despite repeated statements that it is about to do so. AusAID's ad hoc and fragmented approach to delivering aid has been driven from Canberra. Until this year, when staffing has been upgraded, only a small number of staff were on the ground in Dili.

Many complain that AusAID staff spend too much time closely monitoring programs, and too little time attending to the big picture or improving program performance. AusAID has no capacity on the ground to collect or analyse data. It cannot focus on delivering outcomes or on finding out what has worked and what has not. AusAID lacks transparency. It does not provide progress indicators for specific programs. Nor does it publish evaluation studies to report successes or failures.

To forge a new basis for its relations with East Timor, a new bilateral agreement is needed, based on the strong common interest of both countries to reduce poverty on a large scale over an extended period.

Australia also needs to address the concern of the Timorese government to gain access to the Australian labour market for temporary work and on-the-job training. It also needs to help provide more local benefit to the Timorese economy from the exploitation of its only major economic asset: its oil and gas reserves.

A more effective aid program has to be a core element in a new relationship. Program funding should be for ten years or more. A much greater focus on reducing poverty at all levels is needed. Changes need to be made on the basis of published reports on the success of programs. If Australia is to have a greater impact in the second decade of East Timor's existence, it needs to develop a much stronger and integrated local capacity.

Richard CurtainDr Richard Curtain is a public policy consultant specialising in youth policy and youth labour markets.

Topic tags: east timor, dili, australia, Angelita Pires, attempted assassination, José Ramos-Horta, Alfredo Reinado



submit a comment

Existing comments

Not sure if you have heard of the work being undertaken by the Victorian Government, former Premier Steve Bracks, Commissioner Greg Vines, but they are spending considerable time and money in East Timor, with some success. Trust this is of some interest.

Mick Barker | 17 July 2009  

I would like to hear a summary of the works and personal contributions made by individuals and NGOs in East Timor. Does such a comprehensive report exist?

Ray O'Donoghue | 17 July 2009  

Very much agree with your article,having been involved with Timor Lorosa`e since '99 I have witnessed the failure of Ausaid and most NGO`s first hand.Bureaucrats don't seem to understand the meaning of empowerment and the dignity a family feels if the breadwinner is able to provide the basics without handouts.
So similar to the lack of empowerment and opportunities for meaningful employment suffered by our indigenous people in the Kimberley.

The close contact between our media and the Fretilin mouthpiece Joe T must cast doubts as to Xanana's continuing commitment to the people. If anyone reads this, please be assured that his resolve to lift his people from poverty will never fade but without the dependence that Donors seem to want to continue.

Graham williams | 17 July 2009  

Similar Articles

League tables short-change students

  • Fatima Measham
  • 15 July 2009

Studies correlate teacher morale with student achievement, so ranking schools according to student performance may be counterproductive if it hurts teacher morale. Finland has the best education system in the world without resorting to league tables.


National pride begets blind arrogance

  • Michael Mullins
  • 13 July 2009

Assumptions that detained businessman Stern Hu could not be guilty because he is Australian show how national pride can cloud perceptions. Something similar was at play in calls for Kevin Rudd to lobby the Pope for the canonisation of Mary MacKillop.



Subscribe for more stories like this.

Free sign-up