Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site

Egyptian musicians' night in limbo

The Band's Visit: 86 minutes. Rated: M. Director: Eran Kolirin. Starring: Sasson Gabai, Ronit Elkabetz, Saleh Bakri, Khalifa Natour, Shlomi Avraham

The Band's Visit During the opening seconds of The Band's Visit, the camera lingers on a white bus parked at an airport in Israel. After a few moments the bus trundles aside, like the rickety curtain in an amateur theatre, to reveal a line of eight men in sky blue uniform.

They are the Alexandria Police Orchestra, invited to perform at the opening of a new cultural centre. Standing at ease with pressed uniforms and starched-cotton dignity, they wait, just long enough for their patience to seem absurd. Someone has forgotten them.

From this first instance, The Band's Visit strikes a tone that is at once funny and sad. It's a delicate balance that is sustained throughout the short, understated film, which prods cross-cultural disparity for gentle humour and stirs the humanity of its simple story.

The band members find themselves stranded in a nearby, isolated township, and at the mercy of the hospitality of the staff of a shabby diner. The film subsequently focuses on the particular experiences of three of the musicians.

Conductor Tawfiq Zacharya (Gabai), softly spoken, eminently respectable and tinged with secret grief, is taken under the wing of the diner's gregarious owner, Dina (Elkabetz). It seems she views him as a potential sexual conquest, but there's affection as well. The evening they share is more intimate than a physical encounter. It provides the opportunity for Tawfiq to surrender his sadness, even if ultimately the opportunity is missed.

Young lothario Haled (Bakri) — accustomed to wooing girls with a few short bars of 'My Funny Valentine' — finds himself playing the reluctant cupid when he goes out on the town with the hapless Papi (Shlomi Avraham) and his luckless date.

Previously Haled has been both a son-figure and a rival to the band leader Tawfiq. The film's juxtaposition of their contrasting experiences reveals the complexity of their — ostensibly, merely antagonistic — feelings towards each other.

Meanwhile, veteran clarinet player and aspiring conductor Simon (Natour) intermittently ponders the concerto he had begun to write before he got married. In his host's troubled family home, he may find an unexpected ending to his interrupted masterpiece.

Promotional material describes this as a film about a 'lost band in a lost town'. It is important that the story takes place within a social vacuum. It's a night spent in limbo where the characters, unable to move forward, are forced into stillness in order that they may seek within and try to find themselves. In some cases, they succeed.

Official movie website

Tim KroenertTim Kroenert is Assistant Editor of Eureka Street. His articles have been published by The Age, Inside Film, the Brisbane Courier Mail and ASif. He is a contributor to the inaugural edition of the journal Studies in Australian Weird Fiction. Email Tim


Topic tags: Tim Kroenert, film review, The Band's Visit, Eran Kolirin, Sasson Gabai, Ronit Elkabetz, Saleh Bakri



submit a comment

Similar Articles

'Still angry' over Palm Island custody death

  • Pat Mullins
  • 04 July 2008

Jeff Waters relates the death in custody of Mulrunji Doomadgee on Palm Island and the acquittal of the police officer involved. Mulrunji's death reflects a nationwide context where cherished institutions of western democracy are unavailable to many Indigenous people.


Her words' worth

  • Morag Fraser
  • 02 July 2008

When we began Eureka Street in 1991, it was a given that we'd publish a cryptic crossword. I like to believe it was divinely ordained that it should be Joan, only and always, who'd keep us gridded, intellectually tempered and clued up.