Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site


Politicians stoke the violence myth

  • 26 November 2010

I used to carry a knife in my handbag. Like nearly a quarter of Australians, I believe that 80 per cent of all crime is violent crime; I was concerned for my safety. And then I discovered that if my self-defence weapon were used, it would likely be used against me. So, I turned it in during the knife Amnesty month. Which was good, because the police were granted stop-and-search powers, and had I encountered a police officer, I would have been fined.

But the greater police visibility and ability for them to actually do things didn't alleviate my anxieties much — their increased presence only met the increase in street fighting. So I bit the bullet and cut down on spending time outside my home.

For a while, I felt that I was safe there, until I learnt the majority of violent crimes occur within the residential home. So now I spend most of my time inside the municipal library reading the papers and considering just how it got so bad. I'm sure it has a lot to do with youths.

Our society, like every other, has elements of violence. But the public's perception of it is disproportionate: almost one quarter of Australians believe violence is involved in 80 per cent of all crimes committed. The figure is below 10 per cent. The media and politicians have played a role in producing the hysteria.

I can't discern why crime and punishment is such a vital populist concern — perhaps because it plays into the good vs evil binaries that much of our culture is framed in. But frequently we see distasteful campaign of fear mongering, such as that which has characterised the lead-up to Victoria's state elections.

Crime involving violence accounts for fewer than one in ten of all crimes committed in Australia. In the past decade, overall crime rates have decreased significantly. Yet a majority of Australians believe crime rates have risen, and that fewer convicted criminals are given jail sentences than actually are.

A report published by the Australian Institute of Criminology in July indicates that the demographics most likely to over-estimate crime rates are those who are less likely to be victims of crime: the elderly, and females. Young males, who are most commonly its victims, tend to estimate crime rates most accurately.

Political leaders routinely