Welcome to Eureka Street

back to site


The Coalition's special disrespect for unions

  • 06 November 2017


The raid on the offices of the Australian Workers Union by the Australian Federal Police demonstrates a disrespect for trade unions contrary to the Catholic tradition. Since the papal encyclical Rerum Novarum in 1891 Catholic Social Teaching has recognised the right of workers to join together collectively in unions as an important element of the search for the common good in a market economy. The political theatre indulged in by the Employment Minister Michaelia Cash and the Registered Organisations Commission is especially worrying for the deeper attitudes it reveals.

That such a raid was deemed an acceptable way of going about government and police business is a clear statement that unions are fair game in a way that other organisations, like business, charities, and churches are not. No organisation should be treated that way in a democratic society. Unions are clearly disrespected.

We read daily of apparently criminal behaviour by organisations like banks and other large corporations, the RSL in NSW and the Catholic Church, but none of them are treated to a visit by a squad from the AFP. Only suspected terrorist cells are treated this way. The other matters of misuse of scarce police resources and tip offs to the media by ministerial staff are ultimately of secondary importance.

Trade unions have a lowly status, lower than for many years, and consequently union leaders have a weak voice in national public debate. Sally McManus, the relatively new Secretary of the Australian Council of Trade Unions, is treated in an offhand way by the media. She is given her say but is rarely treated with the respect accorded to others in similar positions, like business leaders. Her status outside the tent is painfully clear.

This conclusion will be hotly contested by those who would point to the special relationship that unions enjoy within the labour movement. Union affiliation with the Labor Party does give them special benefits at the federal and state level. Unions cement that relationship through generous election campaign donations, and union leaders consequently have privileged access to parliament.

However, they are condemned by their special relationship with Labor to suffer exclusion from power and influence when Labor is out of office. They made that bargain more than a century ago and have learned to live with it. They are also regularly dragged into political power plays between Labor and the Coalition because to weaken unions is to weaken Labor as a