The cruelty at Manus Island



As I write, staff of the Australian immigration authority and their security contractors are working hard to close the detention centre on Manus Island in Papua New Guinea, where Australia has held over 900 refugees for the last four years.

Dom Hélder CâmaraThe consequences of their actions for the refugees held at the Manus centre are already severe. Detained refugee Behrouz Boochani, a Kurdish journalist and filmmaker has reported on this over the past week for The Saturday Paper and in regular posts on Facebook and Twitter.

The closure of the Manus Island camp might be worth a certain grim approval if the rest of the message of refugees and their supporters had been heeded. We have been demanding that the government close both camps, and also that the people interned there are brought to Australia and able to live freely in the community. #CloseTheCamps was always followed by #BringThemHere and #LetThemStay.

Such demands were somewhat mollified earlier this year by the promise that refugees would be able to settle in the United States, following negotiations made with the Obama administration that were eventually also consented to by the current administration. We know now that this was fake news.

So not only have those detained on Manus Island been lied to and denied settlement in the United States; the Australian Government immigration authority and its contractors are being as brutal in closing the camp as they have been in running it.

They are attempting to force the refugees out of the centre, cutting off water and power and threatening arrest if refugees refuse. But, the refugees are refusing. As has already become abundantly clear, life outside the centre means exposure to even more danger. Further attacks on refugees from Manus Island locals, who live under the strain of high levels of poverty and unemployment and anti-refugee propaganda, can only be expected to continue.

As Boochani reported last week: 'The pressure on the refugees is increasing day by day. Today they cut the water in Foxtrot, the largest compound in Manus detention centre, and they are planning to cut the power soon … I am asking all of those advocates who are fighting for change to Australia's illegal and dangerous refugee policies to be with the refugees in this historical period.'

The Australian-run offshore immigration detention on Manus Island may be soon at an end, but the Australian Government seems hell-bent on ensuring those detained continue to face abuse. And this abuse continues to be what the refugees resist.


"I really wonder how Australia is violating human rights in this remote island but the organisations who claim they are fighting for human rights are mostly silent."


In a recent missive, Boochani looks us in the eye and says: 'Pressure is increasing inside the prison camp, and on the other side the attacks on the refugees in Lorengau town are increasing.

'The ABF plan is to put pressure on both sides to force the refugees to go back to their countries. I really wonder how Australia is violating human rights in this remote island but the organisations who claim they are fighting for human rights are mostly silent.

'Most of the media don't care about current situation in Manus prison camp. Please become our voice.'


Ann DeslandesAnn Deslandes is a freelance writer and researcher from Sydney. Read her other writing at and tweet her @Ann_dLandes.

Topic tags: Ann Deslandes, Manus Island, refugees



submit a comment

Existing comments

Another tragic death, just another day on Manus. Where is the public outcry?The silence of the Australian people in the face of the continuing tragedy on Manus is as evil as the policy that keeps people detained there. We are all complicit. RIP Hamed.

Lisa Stewart | 09 August 2017  

Barbaric. Poor fella my country in the throes of its decline and abandonment of all the good that Hellenic civilisation, The Renaissance and Christianity bequeathed us. The pagan, humanistic philosophers of ancient Greece must be spinning in their graves. "And Jesus wept".

john frawley | 09 August 2017  

What are our Catholic Parishes doing to combat this blatant discrimination against refugees ? Where are the signs. Outside every church saying"bring them here" Who do we follow? ? Jesus? Or do we let our own fears dictate our actions. Perhaps there would be more attending our worship at Mass if we allowed ourselves to be inspired by Pope Francis, who is undoubtedly proclaiming Christ in his messages.. We are not Christians if we don't help refugees!!

Bernie | 09 August 2017  

Bernie - Christian churches have enough money, resources, and moral authority under the current regime to make a difference right now, I think. They could band together and arrange for the refugees to be evacuated to Australia now and be sheltered in the homes of Australians willing to do this. Ask your parish priest or local minister if they'd be willing to consider this.

Ann | 09 August 2017  

Similar Articles

It is time to stop equivocating about domestic violence

  • Sean Lau
  • 01 August 2017

As the responses poured in to the ABC’s story on domestic violence in evangelical churches, I was reminded of the discomfort Saint Augustine showed, in The Confessions, towards his father beating his mother. But he still praised his mother for placating her husband to avoid beatings, and for criticising wives who were beaten. Augustine, then, while possibly opposing domestic violence, had no idea what to do about it, and endorsed behaviour that made it worse.


Ordinary Catholics must help with reform

  • Kevin Liston
  • 31 July 2017

There are many reform movements active in the Catholic Church. Most seem to focus on changing the structures and systems of the church, on reshaping doctrinal positions and updating teachings. Organisational reform is necessary and long overdue but there is also need for a complementary movement among ordinary Catholics.  



Subscribe for more stories like this.

Free sign-up